• Home Home

Commenters mock photo of massive lakeside home with strange design: 'Just doesn't sit right with me'

"This is an absolute crime."

A photo of a large lakeside "McMansion," shared by a Redditor, has set off quite the debate in an online community.

Photo Credit: Reddit

A photo of a large lakeside house has set off quite the debate after a Redditor took to the r/McMansionHell community to question the design, as well as the priorities, behind the building of what the post labels an "Amateur McMansion." 

"Is it just me or is this house like really … vanilla?" the poster wrote, adding, "Something about this house just doesn't sit right with me."

A photo of a large lakeside "McMansion," shared by a Redditor, has set off quite the debate in an online community.
Photo Credit: Reddit

The image shows a large, presumably newly constructed home perched near a lake. Much of the house is bright white, and some commenters described it as boring. 

While the house appears luxurious, with what look to be high ceilings and expansive windows, the overall aesthetic struck several community members as unimaginative.

"For something on the water, this is an absolute crime of banality," one commenter wrote.

"I've built more beautiful homes out of Legos," another user quipped.


In counterpoint, a few commenters wondered if the photo showed the home before final features were added, and a few users defended the style or debated whether it qualified as a "McMansion."

A few commenters pondered how this home fared with sustainability. Whether or not the photo truly shows a "McMansion," homes of this apparent scale, with a vast interior, high ceilings, and oversized windows, often require substantial energy to heat and cool, not to mention significant resources to build and maintain. 

"I dread to think how little insulation this thing has," a Redditor said of the pictured home.

While the online conversation mostly focused on the home's aesthetics, the image highlights a broader issue tied to modern home design: efficiency. 

When was your home built?

Less than 10 years ago 👶

10-25 years ago 🧒

25-50 years ago 🧑

Over 50 years ago 👴

Click your choice to see results and speak your mind.

Energy-efficiency measures can save money and reduce waste in homes of any size. Using recycled or locally sourced building materials, and designing for better insulation or passive heating can make a measurable difference in saving money and reducing impact.

Even choices such as installing energy-efficient windows or opting for drought-tolerant landscaping can save on costs and help offset a large home's environmental footprint without compromising comfort or style.

Homeowners looking to use cleaner and ultimately cheaper energy — and to reduce the pollution associated with their home energy use — can incorporate solar panels.

As housing trends lean toward bigger, more polished designs, the challenge lies in blending visual appeal with long-term sustainability. Whether it's through smarter energy use or thoughtful design, the "vanilla" home by the lake is a solid reminder that beauty and sustainability could coexist in the modern dream home.

💰Get TCD's free newsletters for easy tips to save more, waste less, and make smarter choices — and earn up to $5,000 toward clean upgrades in TCD's exclusive Rewards Club.

Cool Divider