Rural homeowners in Idaho are facing an insurance crisis. Companies are dropping coverage or doubling rates due to growing wildfire risks.

What's happening?

According to a report from Idaho News 6, residents in areas like Garden Valley are being left uninsured. David Hoffman, a resident for a decade, was recently dropped. After calling nearly 20 companies, he received one offer that was double his previous rate.

"We're all being canceled," Hoffman told Idaho News 6. "I can't afford it."

Boise County Sheriff Scott Turner confirmed the problem is widespread. He gets calls from neighbors who can't afford the rising rates. 

"The answer is, they can't afford it, so they just go without," Turner said.

This is happening despite residents' best efforts. The county's Wildfire Mitigation Administrator, Jordan Jones, noted that even when homeowners do everything they can, "it's evidently still not enough."

Why is this insurance crisis concerning?

This isn't an isolated issue; it's a financial crisis. 

According to Capital Press, 27,798 policies in Idaho were non-renewed in 2023. That's a massive jump from 3,900 the year before. Statewide average premiums also climbed, rising from $1,468 to $1,798 in just one year.

This corporate pullback leaves families financially exposed. A home is the largest asset most people own, and without insurance, they risk losing everything.

The problem is partially linked to human activity. The burning of dirty energy sources has created planet-overheating pollution. This leads to hotter, drier conditions and more extreme wildfire seasons, which have made insurance companies cut coverage.

Do you think you pay too much for car insurance? Definitely 😡 My rate is good 👍 It's hard to say 🤷 Rates are too high in general 📈 Click your choice to see results and speak your mind.

This isn't just happening in Garden Valley. Another report detailed how homeowners in the Boise Foothills are also being dropped. In California, the state's "last-resort" insurance plan is now seeking a 36% rate hike.

What's being done about this issue?

Unlike 26 other states, Idaho does not offer a state-run "FAIR Plan" for homeowners who can't get coverage. Instead, some officials are encouraging residents to "harden" their homes with fire-resistant materials.

While these individual efforts are important, the crisis highlights the need for systemic change. 

The most effective long-term solution is to address the root cause of the worsening wildfires: our planet's overheating. This requires transitioning away from dirty fuels and supporting clean energy. There's plenty of insightful information available for anyone who would like a better understanding of this and other important issues.

Hoffman, the Garden Valley resident, believes the issue is urgent and widespread.

"This affects the majority of Idaho, most of Idaho is rural, so it affects people from here to Canada," he told Idaho News 6. "This is a big deal. Insurance companies need to stop being bullies, and taking advantage of people financially."

💰Get TCD's free newsletters for easy tips to save more, waste less, and make smarter choices — and earn up to $5,000 toward clean upgrades in TCD's exclusive Rewards Club.