While it's true that manufacturing solar panels, wind turbines, and batteries involves harmful carbon pollution, research consistently shows that clean energy sources generate far less pollution over their lifetimes compared to dirty energy sources.
In a post on the r/TheWhyFiles subreddit, one Redditor argued that the hidden costs of green energy make it less environmentally friendly than people think. The Why Files is a popular YouTube channel that centers around unexplained mysteries, legends, and conspiracies.
The original poster, prompted by a Why Files episode discussing green energy, suggests that producing and maintaining green energy infrastructure — such as wind turbines and solar panels — creates a substantial carbon footprint.
"One hour of green energy ... makes you feel warm and fuzzy inside," they wrote, "but the reality is, the carbon footprint is massive."
Their argument hinges on the idea that green energy systems require extensive supply chains, industrial processes, and financial infrastructures that all contribute to pollution.
However, even when accounting for the carbon footprint of their production, green energy sources drastically reduce long-term pollution if they produce electricity in place of dirty energy sources — as summarized by Our World in Data and the World Resources Institute.
Moreover, lifecycle assessments show that renewable energy infrastructure repays its carbon debt within just a few years of operation.
Wind turbines, for example, offset the pollution from their production in less than a year, according to several studies, while estimates indicate that solar panels take about one to four years (or about three years, on average) to break even on carbon pollution. After that, wind and solar sources can generate decades of nearly zero-emission energy.
Switching to clean energy reduces pollution and improves public health and economic stability. Renewable energy reduces air pollution, which has been linked to asthma, heart disease, and other respiratory illnesses. Additionally, solar and wind power are now cheaper than coal and gas in many parts of the world, meaning consumers can save money on energy bills.
|
Do you think America has a plastic waste problem? Click your choice to see results and speak your mind. |
Definitely 👍 This Reddit post has sparked a heated debate in the comments. One user said: "This episode fell flat for me. … The green energy is a scam bit clearly lacked any real understanding or research."
TCD Picks » Upway Spotlight
💡Upway makes it easy to find discounts of up to 60% on premium e-bike brands
In the comment section, the original poster noted: "The scam is not the energy that is being sold, it's the game."
The conversation around green energy is nuanced, but the data is clear: Clean energy significantly reduces pollution, benefits public health, and saves consumers money. While it's important to acknowledge the challenges of transitioning away from dirty energy, dismissing renewable energy as a "scam" overlooks its undeniable advantages.
Join our free newsletter for weekly updates on the latest innovations improving our lives and shaping our future, and don't miss this cool list of easy ways to help yourself while helping the planet.
Cool Picks
