• Home Home

Homeowners contentiously debate heat pump benefits after old furnace calls it quits: 'There are huge rebates out there'

"Am I crazy for thinking the best long term purchase here is to get a new heat pump?"

"Am I crazy for thinking the best long term purchase here is to get a new heat pump?"

Photo Credit: iStock

Heat pumps have tons of financial and environmental benefits, but it's not always easy to commit to switching to one from your traditional furnace. Fortunately, there's the r/hvacadvice subreddit for anyone considering that change but still feeling uncertain.

One Reddit user turned to the community to explain an HVAC predicament that was forcing them to make a tough choice. 

"My mother-in-law's 21-year-old furnace just got a $1500 quote to fix. We are looking into replacing the unit entirely," the OP wrote. "I read a lot about heat pumps and how great they are, but I don't know if it changes things if they already have access to gas."

Which of these factors would most effectively motivate you to buy a heat pump?

Lower energy bills 💰

Better temperature control 🌡️

Helping the planet 🌎

I'd never buy a heat pump 🚫

Click your choice to see results and speak your mind.

"Am I crazy for thinking the best long-term purchase here is to get a new heat pump and replace the ductwork to provide both heat and AC?" they then asked.


💡Save thousands with a heat pump


A heat pump can save you thousands of dollars in heating and cooling costs — but first you have to find the right installer at the right price.

Use EnergySage's free tool today to find local options, compare prices, and see how much you can save.

GET QUOTES

EnergySage | Heat Pumps

The Cool Down may receive a commission on signups made through links on this page, but we only promote partners we vet and believe in. For more cool tips like this one, check out our solutions marketplace here.

The ensuing comments were fairly contentious, with many pointing to the benefits of heat pumps and others suggesting to stick with natural gas. Both make good points, but the natural gas contingent missed two crucial things: the OP's location and the Inflation Reduction Act.

The OP is located in Charlotte, which means heat pumps are a fantastic option. Not only are they more energy efficient and, therefore, cost-effective than gas furnaces, but they also provide hot and cold air. That can be incredibly convenient for those humid North Carolina summers.

Heat pumps can also be far more affordable thanks to rebates offered through the IRA. However, the OP should just bear in mind that the current administration has frequently discussed eliminating the program. That means acting right away is crucial. 

If you're interested in installing a heat pump, consider using EnergySage's Heat Pump Marketplace. They offer free quotes from local installers and provide advisors to guide you through the process.

Many commenters offered some useful tips.

"There are huge rebates out there, especially for low-income people. But they only apply when gas heat is replaced with heat pump," one person responded. "And in an area that rarely gets 'really cold' like Charlotte, it's a no-brainer."

"I've had a heat pump in my other home for 15 years, and it's been great. I have no hesitation to switch," another wrote.

Join our free newsletter for easy tips to save more and waste less, and don't miss this cool list of easy ways to help yourself while helping the planet.

Cool Divider