• Business Business

Court issues major ruling in battle over controversial power plant: 'Gotten away with injustices'

"Authorities must protect people and future generations."

A 3,000-megawatt power plant, fired by gas, that was set to be built in South Africa, has had its proverbial plug pulled — at least temporarily.

Photo Credit: Getty Images

A 3,000-megawatt power plant fired by gas that was set to be built in South Africa has had its proverbial plug pulled — at least temporarily. 

The project was initially opposed in 2022, when the South Durban Community Environmental Alliance and Groundwork said that, according to Mongabay, the gas-powered plant was "inconsistent with South Africa's commitment to decarbonization." 

But the South African court ruled in favor of Eskom.

Now, the South African Supreme Court of Appeal has reversed that ruling, for reasons "including the failure to adequately consult local residents and consider the full impacts of the power plant's entire life cycle on climate change," according to Mongabay.

While many African countries have made commitments to transitioning to greener energy and have begun moving away from coal toward gas, the production of gas in a plant like the one proposed still releases dangerous amounts of methane into the atmosphere.

This ruling champions community input, meaning that future plans will need to involve greater consultation with the nearby residents they will affect. 

FROM OUR PARTNER

Find the best HVAC solution to heat and cool your home more efficiently

Mitsubishi Electric’s efficient heating and cooling HVAC solutions can help you stay comfortable no matter the weather or region. You can even regulate temperatures in each room with individually controlled all-electric heat pump systems.

With an energy-efficient, all-climate system from Mitsubishi, you can reduce the amount of energy needed to heat and cool your home, receive up to $2,000 in tax credits, and get peace of mind knowing you’re choosing rigorously tested, high-quality products.

While Eskom, the largest electricity generator in Africa, has been able to expand its nuclear capacity to modernize South Africa's power grid, it has also faced controversy. In 2021, the Centre for Research on Energy and Clean Air reported that Eskom was only behind India in planet-warming sulfur dioxide pollution. 

In August, Business Leadership South Africa accused the company of subverting the nation's attempts at energy reform. "Eskom's current strategy of litigation and obstruction is directly undermining South Africa's national goal of achieving energy security," the organization wrote in a media statement.

According to Reuters, Desmond D'Sa of the South Durban Community Environmental Alliance said: "Eskom, for too long as a state (company), has gotten away with injustices and people that have lived alongside its facilities will suffer from the ... high levels of pollution." 

Groundwork's Yegeshni Moodley said of the recent nullification, according to Mongabay: "This ruling shows that environmental authorities must protect people and future generations, not fossil fuel interests."

How would you feel about a nuclear power plant being built near your home?

I'd be excited 😀

I'd be scared 😨

I'd be angry 😠

I wouldn't care 🤷

Click your choice to see results and speak your mind.

Join our free newsletter for good news and useful tips, and don't miss this cool list of easy ways to help yourself while helping the planet.

Cool Divider