Hundreds of residents sue oil giants after disaster devastates major industry: 'This is a no-win situation'

The Gulf Coast's seafood industry is still reeling after a major oil spill disrupted one of its most important seasons. Now, thousands of shrimpers and seafood businesses are fighting back in court.

What's happening?

More than 2,300 shrimpers, boat owners, and seafood businesses across the Gulf Coast are suing two companies after a major spill disrupted their livelihoods. NOLA News reported that the case, filed in Houston, stems from a 2022 incident when a storage tank on Hilcorp's offshore platform collapsed during an oil transfer. The accident released about 14,000 gallons of crude oil into nearby waters on the very first day of shrimping season.

The slick spread into Lake Pelto, a vital fishing ground, prompting state officials to shut down 33 square miles to oyster harvesting. Though the ban has since been lifted, shrimpers say the damage to their season and their industry's reputation has been severe.

"Do you spend the money for supplies to get rejected at the dock … ? This is a no-win situation for us," Kimberly Chauvin, co-owner of David Chauvin Shrimp Company, told the Houma Courier.

Why is this lawsuit important?

For shrimpers and oyster harvesters already dealing with rising costs, storms, and declining catches, the spill has been devastating. While Hilcorp says independent testing confirmed that shrimp in the area were safe to eat, demand has still suffered due to fears of contamination.

The lawsuit also alleges violations of the federal Oil Pollution Act, accusing Hilcorp and WCC (the company allegedly responsible for damaging the tank) of failing to safeguard against spills. Plaintiffs say the disaster not only damaged boats and gear but also hurt consumer trust in Louisiana's seafood.

A single oil spill can have disastrous effects on an ecosystem, from harming sensitive coastal habitats and wildlife to introducing toxic compounds into the food chain. Not only are oil spills incredibly difficult to truly clean up, but the harm can last for decades or longer.

What's being done about the Hilcorp oil spill?

The plaintiffs are seeking compensation for lost profits, damage to their equipment, and long-term harm to their businesses. They're also calling for restoration of fishing grounds and efforts to repair the reputational damage to Louisiana seafood.

Hilcorp stated that its systems acted quickly to shut down the spill and start cleanup. But this isn't the first time the company has been under scrutiny. Hilcorp reported more than a dozen spills in Louisiana after Hurricane Ida in 2021 and previously paid nearly $1 million in penalties for environmental violations.

By taking these companies to court, the plaintiffs hope to hold them accountable for the damages done — and perhaps incentivize them to behave more responsibly in the future.

Do you think fracking should be illegal in America? Yes — everywhere 👏 Yes — in most areas 👍 In some areas 🤷 No 👎 Click your choice to see results and speak your mind.

Join our free newsletter for good news and useful tips, and don't miss this cool list of easy ways to help yourself while helping the planet.