New York's largest active landfill is seeking permission to accept trash through 2040, despite a report finding methane leaks reaching up to 90 times the federally permitted level and raising concerns about repeated repair failures.
Here's what to know
Seneca Meadows in the Finger Lakes region was among six New York landfills that exceeded federal methane limits, Gothamist reported. Advocacy group Full Circle Future reached that finding after reviewing state Department of Environmental Conservation documents and self-reported data from 16 landfills across the state.
From February 2024 through June 2025, state regulators documented six instances of recurring releases at locations within Seneca Meadows, according to Gothamist. DEC correspondence instructed the operator to repair a leak and retest the location within 120 days.
"These quick patches and fixes don't really stay in place," said Kimenthrie Finlay, Full Circle Future's director of research and analytics and a coauthor of the report, per Gothamist. "In several instances, these fixes didn't work, and that same spot kept recurring."
Finlay noted that the findings likely underestimate emissions, since testing maps indicate that as much as one-third of the landfill goes unmonitored.
More background
Seneca Meadows is approaching its permitted capacity on roughly 400 acres near Seneca Falls, about 275 miles from Midtown Manhattan. The landfill, which opened in 1983, nearly matches the Statue of Liberty in height.
More than 11,000 nearby residents are exposed to the facility's emissions. The landfill receives about 75,000 tons of commercial waste from New York City each year — roughly 6% of its annual intake, according to the DEC's most recent records cited by Gothamist.
Aerial estimates published in the peer-reviewed journal Copernicus identified Seneca Meadows as New York's largest source of methane, a powerful heat-trapping gas.
People at neighboring businesses also contend with the odor daily. Mark Pitifer, an employee at nearby Waterloo Container, likened the smell to having one's head inside a dumpster in a sweltering New York City alley in July, Gothamist reported.
What's being done?
Seneca Meadows could remain open until 2040 if its Texas-based owner, Waste Connections, secures approval for its proposed expansion. Despite its expired permit, the landfill can legally accept trash under an administrative provision that allows operations to continue while its expansion application is under review.
The DEC requires operators to "take appropriate measures and conduct re-monitoring" when addressing methane leaks or excessive emissions, spokesperson Andrea Pedrick-Bird said, per Gothamist.
Waste Connections did not respond to Gothamist's requests for comment.
Yvonne Taylor, cofounder of local advocacy group Seneca Lake Guardian, cited the findings in calling for the site to stop accepting trash.
"The only way that we can start to recover from this heinous mountain of trash is to close it right away, cap it, and start dealing with the problem, not consider letting it grow," Taylor said, per Gothamist. "We need to close this thing. And if we need any more signals, this is it. Time is now. Do it. Close it."
Get TCD's free newsletters for easy tips, smart advice, and a chance to earn $5,000 toward home upgrades. To see more stories like this one, change your Google preferences here.







