A New Jersey school district's effort to reduce student injuries is drawing backlash from parents who say the policy could create a different problem by pushing children away from durable reusable bottles and toward plastic.
In Howell Township Public Schools, the safety measure has turned into a debate over student health, waste, and the kinds of habits schools should be encouraging.
Here's what to know
Serving students from pre-kindergarten through eighth grade across 12 schools, the district told families that metal and glass water bottles, tumblers, and cups would be banned starting in the 2026-27 school year, according to the New York Post.
In a letter signed by Board of Education President Jennifer Okerson and Superintendent Joseph Isola, the district said the decision was driven by safety concerns.
"Metal and glass bottles, tumblers, and cups are rigid, heavy objects that can cause significant injury if thrown, swung, or used during a student altercation," the letter said, per the Post.
The district added that the containers had led to safety concerns and injuries, prompting "this additional precaution to protect our students and staff."
TCD Picks » Quince Spotlight
💡These best-sellers from Quince deliver affordable, sustainable luxury for all
The Post noted it stated that students with banned bottles "will be required to turn it in to the school office, and a parent/guardian may be required to pick it up."
More than 1,000 people signed a Change.org petition called "Reinstate metal and glass water bottles in Howell Township schools," which parent Christine Bastardi started in response.
More background
Reusable metal and glass containers are a practical way to cut down on plastic waste, avoid constantly replacing cheap bottles, and teach children that everyday choices can support a cleaner future.
Bastardi made that argument in the petition, writing, "Our family, like many others, has chosen metal and glass water bottles for the health and environmental benefits they provide."
She pointed to concerns that certain plastic bottles can release chemicals such as BPA into drinking water, something many families are trying to avoid.
What can be done?
Bastardi's petition did not dismiss the district's safety concerns. Instead, it argued for a compromise that would protect students without defaulting to plastic.
"Schools can implement safety checks to ensure all bottles are suitable for school use by verifying that metal and glass bottles adhere to specific standards," she wrote, per the Post.
On Thursday, Isola responded with another letter to parents and guardians in which he outlined rules that allowed students to have metal and stainless steel water bottles, such as storing in a locker outside of the lunch period; glass containers remained prohibited.
Bastardi also suggested offering educational programs about sustainable practices.
"Offering educational programs about the importance of sustainable practices can help nurture responsible habits in students," she wrote in the petition, as the Post noted.
Get TCD's free newsletters for easy tips, smart advice, and a chance to earn $5,000 toward home upgrades. To see more stories like this one, change your Google preferences here.
