• Home Home

Homeowner seeks advice after garden feud turns into neighborhood-wide issue: 'Your rights are the same as the disgruntled neighbor'

"Your best option is rally neighbors to your side."

"Your best option is rally neighbors to your side."

Photo Credit: iStock

An Ohio homeowner's plan for a community garden sprouted into controversy on Reddit, where they shared their story in the r/HOA subreddit.

The post struck a chord, garnering more than 60 comments from sympathetic Redditors.

The original poster thoroughly researched the project, consulted with landscaping companies, surveyed neighbors for input, and developed a comprehensive plan covering costs, location, funding, and long-term maintenance.

The HOA board and management company green-lit the proposal, and the approved plan was emailed to the entire neighborhood before breaking ground.

"Fast forward to a few weeks after, HOA is contacting me about an angry neighbor who is claiming the space we chose is where his kids play," the Redditor wrote. "News to me. He had ample opportunity to state his claim and I objectively would've taken that into consideration."

The neighbor is reportedly rallying others to demand that the nearly finished garden be completely relocated. A board member friendly with the neighbor suggested using HOA funds to move it to a new site hand-picked by the opposition.

Sadly, this homeowner's plight is not unique. Across the country, HOAs have stymied residents attempting to make eco-friendly, cost-saving home improvements like installing solar panels or planting native, drought-resistant lawns.

By blocking such sustainable upgrades, HOAs force homeowners to waste money and resources while contributing to environmental issues like air pollution and water scarcity.

🗣️ How often will you be gardening this summer?

🔘 Every day 🥗

🔘 At least once a week 🥕

🔘 At least once a month 🌱

🔘 I don't garden 🚫

🗳️ Click your choice to see results and speak your mind

Fellow Redditors chimed in with advice for the embattled garden planner.

"Your rights are the same as the disgruntled neighbor. You can both try to convince the board to go your way," one commenter noted. "I would try to involve the other owners and stress how much money would be thrown down the drain."

Another suggested, "Your best option is rally neighbors to your side and put political pressure on the board the other way. Biggest leverage you have is the waste of money the HOA will be spending to move it."

In the face of NIMBY neighbors and rigid regulations, homeowners' best tools for positive change may be passionate advocacy and community collaboration. By working with your HOA instead of against it to change unfair bylaws, the seeds of sustainability can still take root.

Join our free newsletter for easy tips to save more, waste less, and help yourself while helping the planet.

Cool Divider