• Business Business

Spain's 2024 floods drained 40% of its disaster insurance reserves, straining a vital safety net

"Over the long term it could not sustain costs of that scale."

A flood-ravaged street in Spain.

Photo Credit: iStock

As extreme weather has caused increasingly costly damage, keeping disaster coverage affordable has become a growing concern in Spain. The country's devastating 2024 floods used 40% of a crucial insurance fund's reserves, raising worries about the sustainability of insurance models. 

Here's what to know

Mandatory surcharges on qualifying insurance policies fund Spain's Consorcio de Compensación de Seguros. The public body compensates policyholders for extraordinary events such as flooding, seismic damage, and unusually powerful winds, as Green Central Banking reported. The CCS does not cover wildfire or heat wave losses under its extraordinary event protection.

By September 2025, payments from the CCS had covered 207,558 claims totaling €3.64 billion ($3.97 billion) for the Valencia floods, according to Green Central Banking. The company's PERC report estimated the disaster's total economic impact at €20.3 billion ($22.17 billion).

Francisco Solano, a CCS deputy director who oversees studies and international relations, said the fund spent less on its 10 most expensive previous disasters combined than on this catastrophe.

"Its capacity to pay is guaranteed in the short term, but over the long term it could not sustain costs of that scale," warned Pablo Girgado, a specialist in insurance law at Tarragona's Rovira i Virgili University in Spain, per Green Central Banking.

More background

Girgado identified raising the surcharge as one way to replenish reserves, placing more of the cost on policyholders. The surcharge has been uniform across Spain, with charges determined by the insured amount and risk category, not geography. Proponents have argued that this structure helps limit steep price rises for extraordinary risk coverage, including flood coverage.

Juan Manuel López Zafra, a CUNEF University professor and actuary, warned that changing weather patterns have undermined insurers' ability to rely on historical experience to estimate future claims, according to Green Central Banking.

López Zafra emphasized the danger of disasters that hit interconnected regions and economic activities at the same time. Some risks could become "practically impossible to insure," particularly where high exposure is paired with reinsurance — the coverage insurers buy to help absorb losses — that is inadequate or too costly. 

What's being done?

Spain's CCS already shares disaster costs among policyholders, private insurance, and a public institution. Contrary to the skeptics, Solano, the CCS deputy director, said the fund had enough financial resources to handle the Valencia catastrophe and was prepared for rare, high-intensity events, according to Green Central Banking. He also described the public sector's role as complementing private coverage to help keep risks insurable.

Other nations have been facing similar insurance-related dilemmas. France has taken a different approach through its Cat Nat system, which uses private insurers supported by public reinsurance that carries a state guarantee. 

Francisco Lisbona, who leads Zurich Spain's resilience solutions work, urged investment in identifying vulnerabilities, adapting exposed assets, and strengthening businesses and communities, Green Central Banking noted. For businesses, the fallout extends beyond property damage to supplier disruptions and longer recovery times.

For any plan to work, affordability remains a central pillar. 

"A technically correct insurance premium is useless if nobody can afford it, or if there is insufficient insurance capacity," López Zafra said, per Green Central Banking. 

Where can I learn more?

Spain's flood losses highlighted the pressure extreme weather has put on insurance coverage.

• In Spain, floods left two dead and one missing, and Catalonia advised against travel.

• Flash floods in Spain left one person dead after Barcelona was placed under red alert.

• Insurance insiders in the U.K. and Europe said climate risk projections get a "haircut."

• In Ireland, 13,000 flood-risk homes can now obtain insurance as concerns about extreme weather grow.

• The U.K.'s hottest summer triggered 13,000 subsidence claims in three months, with payouts averaging £20,000.

Get TCD's free newsletters for easy tips, smart advice, and a chance to earn $5,000 toward home upgrades. To see more stories like this one, change your Google preferences here.

Cool Divider