• Home Home

Homeowner replaces every smoke alarm in house, only to face more than 10 mysterious false alarms

Insects could set off a detector by interfering with its sensor.

A hand presses the test button on a white smoke detector mounted on the ceiling.

Photo Credit: iStock

A homeowner's effort to make their house safer has become a recurring headache after replacement smoke alarms sounded more than 10 times without an apparent cause.

Here's what to know

In a post on Reddit, the homeowner asked what else they could investigate after common fixes failed to resolve the problem.

"It's driving me insane. What else should we consider? Don't know what to do anymore and while I want my home to be safe, this doesn't feel like it's helping us," they wrote.

Hardwired alarms cover the hallway, each bedroom, and the basement. The homeowner said they replaced every alarm to bring the system up to code after buying the house.

A humidity fan for bathroom ventilation was part of the home's weatherization work, but the alarms kept sounding despite those changes and regular dust removal.

In a follow-up, the homeowner confirmed that the devices are interconnected.

More background

Several commenters pointed to combination smoke and carbon monoxide detectors as a possible source of the problem.

One homeowner said they use smoke-only alarms and separate carbon monoxide detectors after replacing troublesome combination units. The original poster confirmed that their hallway alarm is a combination model.

Another commenter said the manual for their six combination detectors identified three beeps as a malfunction signal. Their units sometimes chirped during showers even though they were more than 10 feet from the bathroom.

Another commenter described moisture setting off a hallway combination detector while a bedroom's smoke detector stayed quiet. A child's humidifier had been running at full blast overnight, and opening the bedroom door released enough moisture to trigger the hallway alarm.

What can be done?

One commenter suggested identifying the alarm that set off the interconnected system.

They explained that, on their units, the test button clears the red light that keeps blinking after an alarm. That light marks the device that triggered the system.

The commenter had once discovered a silverfish inside an alarm and recommended inspecting the unit that triggered the others. Another Redditor said an electrician had told them that insects could set off a detector by interfering with its sensor.

Switching to battery-only alarms, however, drew less support. One commenter noted that the detection technology was largely the same, while another cautioned that replacement devices might not meet code requirements when selling the house.

Where can I learn more?

While annual home maintenance may seem like a costly chore, these stories reiterate the importance of regularly servicing your appliances.

• A former insurance agent cautioned against skipping wood stove maintenance to prevent denied fire claims.

• One new homeowner's water heater inspection revealed a disconnected vent and burnt insulation.

• A New Jersey couple faced a $10,000 furnace replacement quote following a failed tune-up.

Get TCD's free newsletters for easy tips, smart advice, and a chance to earn $5,000 toward home upgrades. To see more stories like this one, change your Google preferences here.

Cool Divider