• Tech Tech

Parent says public school used AI to age up her 6-year-old, sparking privacy fears

"I would be absolutely FURIOUS if my child's school did this."

A self portrait of a child as a nurse.

Photo Credit: Instagram

For one mom, an AI-generated picture from her daughter's school raised concerns about privacy, consent, and the impact on a child's imagination.

Here's what to know

On Instagram, Nikki Anderson (@moms.who.write) said her 6-year-old daughter came home with an AI-generated picture showing what she might look like at 25. She said the AI version of her daughter, who wants to be a nurse, was inspired by her daughter's own artwork of herself in that profession.

"Every single thing about this was a decision that she made," the parent said of her daughter's drawing, as covered as well by The Daily Mail. "What does a nurse look like? What belongs in a hospital? How do I fit in there? That's childhood creativity, imagination, cognitive development."

She went on to compare her daughter's work with the AI version, which she said depicted her child as "young, thin, conventionally attractive," replacing her vision with "an algorithm's interpretation of what a successful adult woman should look like." 

"She already imagined the future," she continued. "What part of that needed to be finished by a computer?" 

She added that she did not give consent for the school to upload her daughter's likeness to a generative AI platform.

More background

AI has become a flashpoint in schools, with parents raising concerns about data privacy, security, consent, and the potential for misuse, as well as its effects on cognitive development. 

While the impacts of AI in schools are still under investigation, one study found that students who used AI had trouble remembering quotes from their essays and displayed 55% less brain activity. 

"Can we at least leave their imaginations alone?" Anderson asked in the Instagram post. "Why do adults feel the need to insert a multibillion dollar industry into something children already do better than us? To what? Make it more impressive? More marketable? More worth looking at?" 

What people are saying

The discussion largely reflected concerns that the potential pitfalls of introducing AI in schools — at least at such a young age — could outweigh the benefits. 

"Training an AI software on a young child's likeness without parental consent should be illegal," one person asserted. 

"Definitely complain," one teacher said. "Better yet, get a group of parents involved. Take it to the school board if necessary."

"I would be absolutely furious if my child's school did this," a third wrote. "It is beyond irresponsible, not to mention the ethical and environmental costs involved." 

Get TCD's free newsletters for easy tips, smart advice, and a chance to earn $5,000 toward home upgrades. To see more stories like this one, change your Google preferences here.

Cool Divider