What was supposed to be a pricey hot-water upgrade became a frightening ordeal when a homeowner came back from errands to a house that smelled strongly of gas.

The episode underscores how quickly routine home projects can turn dangerous — and why a water heater choice can affect more than monthly bills.

Here's what to know

The trouble surfaced almost immediately, according to a post on Reddit's r/askaplumber.

The homeowner said they had spent a lot on the tankless installation and, after the work wrapped up, were away for roughly two hours.

When they got back, the home was "reeking of natural gas."

They said the fire department came out, their animals were taken outside, and the gas company identified the new unit as the source of the leak before shutting off the gas.

Shaken by the incident, the poster wrote, "We could have lost everything."

They said the company owner — the person who had given the original estimate — later came back himself and corrected the issue, explaining that "something was not cut properly, it was rushed and careless."

Among the replies, some readers pointed to how the company handled the problem.

One commenter wrote, "Serious? Absolutely. Having the owner himself come out to fix it asap is meaningful."

Another commenter added, "Mistakes happen and the owner seems like a good person. Didn't try to brush you off and personally came out to fix the issue right away."

Heat pump water heaters are increasingly worth comparing with gas models. Because they move heat instead of creating it through combustion, they can reduce energy use while also avoiding gas burning inside the home.

More background

Tankless gas water heaters are often marketed as efficient upgrades because they heat water on demand instead of continuously maintaining a full tank. However, they still depend on properly installed gas lines, fittings, and venting. If any part of that work is rushed or done carelessly, an expensive upgrade can quickly become a major safety risk.

Some Redditors said the owner's honesty and quick response counted for a lot, while others said accepting the free furnace tune-up sounded reasonable even if the homeowner chooses a different company next time.

One commenter said, "The owner came; he acknowledged the fault and didn't try to lie/bullshit you. These two things make me respect the owner and be understanding that shit does indeed happen even with good people."

What can be done?

Homeowners planning a replacement can protect themselves by getting multiple quotes, verifying licenses, asking who will actually perform the installation, and requesting a leak check or walkthrough before the crew leaves. It is also wise to ask where the gas shutoff is and what to do if fuel is detected.

One option to compare is Cala. Its customizable smart heat pump water heaters help homeowners decrease their energy bills by heating water exactly when it's needed. These systems learn a household's usage patterns and can avoid wasting energy keeping water hot when nobody needs it.

That can be especially helpful for families already facing a major replacement expense. Water heating is one of the larger energy loads in many homes, so choosing an efficient electric model can add up over time. Depending on local rates and what you're replacing, rebates, tax credits, and lower utility bills can all improve the value proposition.

If you're comparing gas tankless systems with electric options, you can look closely at a Cala model alongside other heat pump units before deciding.

Where can I learn more?

After a scare like this, many homeowners want a clearer picture of their options before replacing a major appliance.

• For homeowners weighing replacements, tankless water heater benefits can include lower energy use.

• After four years, one homeowner found a smart heat pump water heater kept saving money.

Get TCD's free newsletters for easy tips, smart advice, and a chance to earn $5,000 toward home upgrades. To see more stories like this one, change your Google preferences here.