• Home Home

Homeowner outraged after returning home to find HOA's destructive act: 'Without my permission'

"Would it be worthwhile pursuing small claims?"

One homeowner was furious to have his native flower garden destroyed by his HOA, prompting him to seek legal advice.

Photo Credit: iStock

After jumping through hoops to add a native flower garden to their yard, one Connecticut homeowner was angry to have that garden destroyed by their homeowner's association anyway.

The strength of their reaction is illustrated by the fact that they posted in r/LegalAdvice looking for help. 

"HOA cut my garden down without permission. Is it worthwhile to go to small claims?" they asked.

It is actually quite common for HOAs to interfere with native plant gardening. Many such associations are more concerned with keeping the neighborhood looking uniform than they are with the incredible benefits of planting native species, such as the savings on water and fertilizer, not to mention the reduced effort to keep your yard healthy and the benefits for native wildlife.

In this case, the original poster did everything they could to work with their HOA and get permission for their garden. 

"I had a garden I planted earlier this year from seed, with native wildflowers. HOA rules that the garden in front of our place we can do what we wish, but things planted must be annuals. Which they were," said the original poster. "I come home today to see that maintenance has completely cut through my tiny wildflower garden. It's nothing but soil now."

FROM OUR PARTNER

Spread the holiday glow with 40% off curated plant-based skincare sets

OM Botanicals is known and loved for delivering food-grade skincare formulations that nourish without harsh chemicals — and this holiday season you can spread the glow with 40% off carefully curated gift sets.

Whether you’re gifting wellness seekers, conscious beauty lovers, or just treating yourself, OM delivers full-spectrum herbal extracts, bioavailable vitamins, and microbiome-friendly ingredients crafted in small batches with artisan-level care.

Learn more

The original poster was angry enough to take legal action. 

"Would it be worthwhile pursuing small claims?" they asked. "If it helps, I'm active duty and would have access to JAG corps."

In many cases, it doesn't take legal action to settle issues like this. Instead, you can use the association's internal processes to change the rules.

That is likely a better course of action than a lawsuit, because as commenters pointed out, there was not much to be gained from suing in this case. 

"How much of a loss do you have?" asked one commenter. "Is that amount of money worth your time?"

How much effort are you willing to make to reduce the amount of plastic and toxins in your home?

I'll do whatever it takes 👍

Only if it's an easy swap 😅

Only if it's cheaper 💰

Not interested 🚫

Click your choice to see results and speak your mind.

Get TCD's free newsletters for easy tips to save more, waste less, and make smarter choices — and earn up to $5,000 toward clean upgrades in TCD's exclusive Rewards Club.

Cool Divider