For three years, East Ridge, Tennessee, homeowner Chester Perry worked to turn his front yard into a thriving pollinator garden, creating a place for bees, butterflies, birds, and other insects to find food and shelter.
However, one day in September, he came home to find three years of hard work destroyed. His garden had been mowed to the ground, and an oak tree was cut down after Perry's appeal over a high-grass citation was diverted into a city spam folder.
Here's what to know
According to AOL, the matter began in September after a nearby resident complained about Perry's property at 3840 Altima Drive. WTVC NewsChannel 9 said the city issued two violations: one tied to general upkeep, which Perry fixed, and another for tall grass, which he chose to appeal.
Chief Building Official Michael Howell said the city allows 10 days to submit an appeal. Perry emailed his appeal about a week after getting the citation, believing he had taken the necessary steps to contest it. But his effort was undermined when the city's firewall filtered the message into spam, so officials never saw it.
Forty days after the city issued the citation, crews removed the plants.
WTVC reported that Perry said he planted the yard to "create a habitat for declining insect populations." When he returned and saw it had been cleared, he said he was "heartbroken and just despondent" as he walked up to "this devastation."
TCD Picks » Quince Spotlight
💡These best-sellers from Quince deliver affordable, sustainable luxury for all
City Manager Brian Koral told WTVC that Perry "did try attempt to file it in good faith." Since the failed appeal was the result of the city's own system, East Ridge said it would not impose the fine that normally follows a cleanup notice.
More background
In its Oct. 25 report, the Chattanoogan said the damage extended beyond the flowers. Perry said many small insects living in the garden were also lost, and workers cut down an oak tree on the property. He said the situation worsened because the yard was left as bare ground.
East Ridge's code does not distinguish between a native garden and overgrown grass. Howell told WTVC that the ordinance makes no carve-outs for native or exotic plants and "doesn't define that."
At a city council meeting, a property owner behind Camp Jordan said she is converting about 2.5 acres of lawn to native plants and argued that East Ridge's height limits conflict with pollinator plants such as purple coneflowers, which reach 3 to 4 feet, and sunflowers, which can grow 8 to 10 feet.
The city's current enforcement system focuses on standard property maintenance cases. East Ridge's Building and Codes Department has one full-time residential inspector and two full-time code enforcement officers, while the city's Administrative Hearing Officer handles property maintenance matters monthly and sends cited residents a mailed hearing notice.
What's being done?
Mayor Brian Williams told the Chattanoogan that he sees the benefits of native yards and that East Ridge must strike a reasonable balance. He also said East Ridge plans to borrow ideas from other cities as officials consider revisiting the ordinance rather than simply defending it.
Residents have begun offering suggestions. One speaker urged the codes department to learn more about native landscaping through the University of Tennessee's Tennessee Smart Yards certification, run alongside the Tennessee Water Research Center, along with a video called "Next Step for Nature."
Perry used his appearance before the council to call for a rule change that would protect yards like his. The request goes beyond his own property to ask whether residents can create wildlife habitat without risking a complaint that treats those plantings as neglect.
Perry's neighbor Taylor Westman told WTVC that her family's connection to the loss was personal, and another Altima Drive resident said flowers may be mistaken for neglect after blooming ends but still supported allowing native gardens.
Speaking to the council after losing his garden, insects, and oak tree, Perry said he wants East Ridge to make room for yards like his and argued society would be better off if people "valued all life great and small."
Where can I learn more?
Similar disputes have left other homeowners dealing with lost landscaping, fines, or threats tied to yard rules.
• In Tennessee, state officials ripped out landscaping and trees during a road-widening fight near one home.
• In Parma, Ohio, a family got a city violation letter a day after a fire.
• In Florissant, Missouri, homeowners heard a bulldozer before learning a greenway could reshape 28 backyards.
• In the UK, tenants could be evicted over unkempt gardens under proposed social housing reforms.
• An HOA board member said a neighbor reported them over uncut grass on adjoining property.
Get TCD's free newsletters for easy tips, smart advice, and a chance to earn $5,000 toward home upgrades. To see more stories like this one, change your Google preferences here.
