• Outdoors Outdoors

Can birch trees supply emergency drinking water? Preppers warn: 'Sap is not water'

"There is a ton of solute and other materials in sap that can be harmful to consume in significant amounts."

A person collecting tree sap.

Photo Credit: iStock

One disaster prepper took to social media to ask if "tapping trees for water" was a reliable option.

In the ensuing Reddit discussion on the site's r/TwoXPreppers forum, commenters overwhelmingly warned the prepper that it was a bad idea.

Here's what to know

In the Reddit thread, the original poster wrote that "I saw something today about tapping a birch tree for the sap, saying that a tree acts as a natural filter. I know you can drink maple sap straight from the tree. Does anybody know or have any experience about this?"

Quickly, commenters flooded the thread with context on why it wasn't a real option.

One of the top comments read, "Not a good idea. If you want to use trees for water, tie a watertight (e.g. hard plastic) bag tightly around a leafy branch, so that it seals. After a day or two, the bag will contain water."

The OP responded to this, doubling down and asking, "Why isn't tapping the tree a good idea? … I'm not trying to argue, I'm just wondering if there is a reason that you wouldn't want to drink sap from trees."

Another user wrote, "Because sap is not water. … There is a ton of solute and other materials in sap that can be harmful to consume in significant amounts." 

What can be done?

For emergency preparation, one participant favored carrying a dependable backcountry water filter rather than relying on tapping equipment, writing, "I can't think of a scenario where I'd have the gear to tap a tree, but not a backcountry water filter."

Another commenter warned of contamination, directly addressing the idea that a tree could serve as a natural filter. As they explained, "Tree sap can be contaminated by microbes like bacteria and fungi, if you choose to tap for drinking purposes I would at least pasteurize it first."

Where can I learn more?

Birch sap is one of several water sources preppers have considered for emergencies. 

• Another prepper sought ways to make pool water drinkable while their preferred filter was backordered.

• A desert prepper's condensation water collection plan drew replies favoring gravity filters over dry air.

• One prepper's plan to pull water from air prompted warnings about draining backup power.

Get TCD's free newsletters for easy tips, smart advice, and a chance to earn $5,000 toward home upgrades. To see more stories like this one, change your Google preferences here.

Cool Divider