• Tech Tech

One-can trick gets ineligible containers accepted, prompting fixes to Singapore's refund machines

"Deliberate manipulation of the machines or fraudulent claims is taken seriously."

A person inserting a plastic bottle into a recycling machine for cans.

Photo Credit: iStock

Videos of apparent misuse encouraged the operator of Singapore's beverage-container refund machines to make adjustments.

Here's what to know

BCRS Ltd. runs Singapore's Beverage Container Return Scheme and has responded to footage of the apparent misuse, according to a Channel News Asia (@ChannelNewsAsia) report on TikTok.

A TikTok user asked, "Is this legal?" alongside a video showing a Return Right reverse vending machine. The video shows a person allegedly using one qualifying can to get the machines to accept ineligible bottles and cans.

A returned container must display the required deposit mark to qualify for the scheme's 10-cent refund.

More background

CNA's TikTok post about the incident had received more than 68,000 views at the time of the snapshot.

Some commenters questioned how the machine was effectively encouraging a circular economy if only certain brands were accepted. Others took to the comments to ridicule the machine's inability to recognize the incorrect cans and suggest that the machine should forgo paying people to recycle. 

"We just make all returnable items the same deposit. Keeps it simple with fewer loopholes," one person said.

What's being done?

BCRS Ltd. said it would continue strengthening safeguards against misuse, according to CNA. The company has also worked with its return network operators to recalibrate the machines following the issue revealed in the videos.

The operator said its machines are monitored around the clock by CCTV and keep digital transaction records.

According to CNA's TikTok caption, BCRS Ltd. also said, "Deliberate manipulation of the machines or fraudulent claims is taken seriously."

While recycling is a great way to divert waste away from incineration and land disposal, things like contamination, material complexity, and cost can make it less effective.

Limiting what items can be recycled might seem counterproductive, but by focusing on the materials that can easily be transformed into new products, businesses are able to streamline the manufacturing process.

Where can I learn more?

• Singapore Grand Prix fans won't pay the deposit on drinks inside the Circuit Park.

• In Germany, a traveler mistook bottle returns for free money before learning the 0.25-euro deposit rule.

• Michigan retailers want bottle and can returns moved out of stores, citing trash concerns.

Get TCD's free newsletters for easy tips, smart advice, and a chance to earn $5,000 toward home upgrades. To see more stories like this one, change your Google preferences here.

Cool Divider