Viewers have questioned whether aspiring artists could lose out on paid work in beauty creator Michelle Phan's new anime project. The backlash centers on Kiss & Makeup, a planned 50-episode anime series that appears to use artificial intelligence to create its artwork.
Here's what to know
According to the Fashion Times, a Reddit poster asked why people working on Phan's planned 50-episode series seemed hesitant to say directly whether they were using artificial intelligence.
"The comments are calling her out for it," the OP wrote. "A guy called Andy who is a part of the project is defending the use of AI without fully saying it's AI. funny how people will use AI but will dance around admitting it, just say it."
They also posted a screenshot of a post from Kiss & Makeup.
Commenters questioned the value of watching a lengthy series if generated artwork replaced artists' own work.
One commenter saw a missed opportunity to give aspiring illustrators and animators paid work. Others felt the announcement put the episode count ahead of the artistic process, according to Fashion Times.
More background
Phan built her following through early YouTube videos on makeup techniques and visual transformations before expanding into other businesses. She co-founded Ipsy, an online beauty subscription service, in 2011. She also created The Enchantress, an online comic drawing on anime, manga, and fantasy art styles, according to the Fashion Times.
Critics of generative AI worry that training data may include copyrighted artwork used without permission, a concern reflected in the backlash to Kiss & Makeup.
Compensation, authorship, and creative credit are also at issue when automated production replaces paid illustration and animation work, separate from questions about how the tools are trained.
AI relies on electricity-powered computing infrastructure, which can require substantial amounts of energy and water for cooling.
While AI can help optimize wind and solar power systems, growing demand for computing power can also strain resources and potentially drive up electricity bills.
What can be done?
A clearer explanation of the production process, including which human artists are involved and what they contribute, would address the transparency concerns raised in the thread.
Phan's interest in illustrated storytelling predates Kiss & Makeup. Speaking with Fast Company in 2015, as reported by Fashion Times, she said a childhood story idea eventually grew into a comic project and called art and illustration passions she's held since childhood.
Get TCD's free newsletters for easy tips, smart advice, and a chance to earn $5,000 toward home upgrades. To see more stories like this one, change your Google preferences here.







