After Apple estimated a screen replacement for a damaged MacBook, the price was high enough that a used replacement laptop started to look like the smarter buy.
For YouTube creator Dawid (@DawidDoesTechStuff), the decision boiled down to spending 1,200 Canadian dollars ($848) on the old machine or paying less for a secondhand MacBook Pro.
Here's what to know
Rather than accept Apple's informal estimate, Dawid documented in a YouTube video how he bought a used first-gen 14-inch Apple Silicon MacBook Pro with 32 gigabytes of RAM and 512 GB of storage for 1,000 Canadian dollars ($706) on Craigslist.
He said that quote came after he had already tried and failed to repair the 16-inch MacBook Pro screen himself.
The repair quote also landed in the context of a broader problem. Dawid said the 16 GB memory configuration in his original laptop had become a bottleneck for editing, making it difficult to justify paying for a machine that "can't handle my workflow anymore."
He said the replacement has fixed that issue in practice. "I still haven't been able to run into RAM limitations with it," Dawid said, adding that "32 gigs is the sweet spot for my workflow on a MacBook."
TCD Picks » Quince Spotlight
💡These best-sellers from Quince deliver affordable, sustainable luxury for all
He also said used pricing did not stay still for long. He saw a 1TB, 16GB version listed on Craigslist for 1,600 Canadian dollars ($1,130), along with another 16GB model at 1,200 Canadian dollars ($848).
More background
The purchase came with some obvious wear. Dawid said the used MacBook showed a sticker mark on the lid, a long scratch across the top, and shiny keys that he initially tried to clean with soap and water before deciding the finish was simply worn down.
There were downsides on performance, too. He said the M1 Pro MacBook ran intensive video game Cyberpunk 2077 at about 26 frames per second at medium settings and felt slow, especially compared with his M2 Pro MacBook, and he said the CPU gap in a benchmarking test tool was "much bigger" than he expected.
For video editing, though, the extra memory mattered more than the speed loss. He said the used M1 Pro suited his editing work better than the broken-screen M2 Pro, even though exports took longer.
Dawid also said the 14-inch display felt too small for working on the go, while the older laptop's HDMI output was limited to 4K 60Hz on his home monitor, compared with 4K 240Hz from the newer M2 Pro system.
What can be done?
His takeaway was specific rather than universal. Users should check repair pricing against the used market instead of assuming a repair will cost less. In his case, local Craigslist listings turned up a MacBook with better specs for less than Apple's screen estimate.
That logic also shaped the specs he prioritized. Dawid was willing to live with 512GB of internal storage because he already edits off an external SSD, but he intentionally looked for 32GB of RAM because memory was the more important constraint in his workflow.
Across his testing, he looked at cosmetic condition, screen size, RAM headroom, app performance, and port limits. Overall, he was pleased with the outcome.
"I'm very excited that I didn't have to give Apple a bunch of money, so that's cool," Dawid concluded.
Where can I learn more?
If you're comparing repair costs with the used market, there are other ways to save on Apple gear.
• Loop Mobile has sold cheap refurbished Apple products, including MacBooks and iPhones, at lower prices.
• Apple's trade-in program for old MacBooks has kept devices circulating instead of heading to landfills.
• Lenovo has pushed repair and recycling options as alternatives to replacing aging laptops.
Get TCD's free newsletters for easy tips, smart advice, and a chance to earn $5,000 toward home upgrades. To see more stories like this one, change your Google preferences here.
