• Tech Tech

Cancer concerns fuel push for 90% cut in US drinking water nitrate limit

The analysis projected $364.1 billion in health savings.

A person fills a glass with water from a faucet.

Photo Credit: iStock

Concerns about cancer and other long-term health risks are prompting calls to lower the federal limit for nitrates in drinking water, a change advocates say could prevent thousands of illnesses.

Here's what to know

A petition to the Environmental Protection Agency seeks a 90% cut in the nitrate limit for drinking water, Wisconsin Public Radio reported. The 16 local and national organizations behind it want a limit of 1 milligram per liter rather than the current 10 milligrams per liter.

Food & Water Watch, Midwest Environmental Advocates, and Clean Wisconsin are among the petitioners.

Sara Walling, who directs Clean Wisconsin's water and agriculture program, said the limit was designed to prevent blue baby syndrome, in which infants' blood is deprived of oxygen. The EPA introduced the threshold as an interim measure in 1975 before adopting it in 1991.

Wisconsin Public Radio reported that research on drinking water nitrates has found elevated risks of colon, kidney, and stomach cancers with high exposure.

After reviewing more than 30 human health studies, the petitioners argued that the research behind the existing standard, which dates to the 1950s, needs updating.

More background

An analysis commissioned by the groups and conducted by One Water Econ, a Colorado-based consulting firm, estimated that exposure at or above the proposed nitrate threshold affects almost 120 million people, Wisconsin Public Radio reported.

The petitioners say lowering the limit could prevent 1,900 cases of colorectal cancer along with 440 ovarian cancer cases and 2,180 very low birth weight cases, according to Wisconsin Public Radio.

The petition's analysis of federal data identifies Wisconsin as one of the 10 states with the highest average nitrate concentrations in groundwater.

Manure and fertilizer applied to fields contribute to nitrate contamination in Wisconsin's groundwater; agriculture is responsible for roughly 90% of the total.

Using samples collected from 2021 to 2023, One Water Econ identified 383 Wisconsin water systems serving nearly 1.5 million people where nitrate concentrations met or exceeded 1 milligram per liter, Wisconsin Public Radio reported.

What's being done?

Federal drinking water regulations must undergo review every six years under the Safe Drinking Water Act. EPA spokesperson Jake Murphy said the agency would review the petition.

During a 2024 review, the agency determined that the nitrate rule "was not a candidate for revision," Murphy said. The EPA will consider newly available studies during its next evaluation.

Over 50 years, One Water Econ estimated compliance expenses of $94.5 billion for treatment and ongoing operations and maintenance, according to Wisconsin Public Radio. The same analysis projected $364.1 billion in health savings.

Jim Eckberg, director of science and innovation at Green Bay-based Edge Dairy Farmer Cooperative, noted farmers' efforts to reduce their environmental impact, Wisconsin Public Radio reported. He said the cooperative was unfamiliar with the petition.

"We are encouraged by current work being done on farms to protect water quality and realize there is still opportunity in farmer-led innovation for holistic approaches to address these challenges," Eckberg said.

Get TCD's free newsletters for easy tips, smart advice, and a chance to earn $5,000 toward home upgrades. To see more stories like this one, change your Google preferences here.

Cool Divider