• Home Home

Toilet kept refilling every 2 minutes, causing a spike in one homeowner's water bill

"How do I go about fixing this toilet so it quits refilling constantly?"

A person uses a screwdriver to repair the inside of a toilet tank.

Photo Credit: iStock

A toilet that keeps refilling may seem like a small annoyance, but it could cost you. For one homeowner, a constantly refilling toilet seemed to waste up to 80 gallons of water each day and contribute to rising water bills. They took to Reddit's r/askaplumber for advice. 

Here's what to know

"How do I go about fixing this toilet so it quits refilling constantly?" they asked, explaining that their water meter was clicking "about 0.1 every few minutes."  

A loss of 0.1 gallons every two minutes may not seem like a lot, but it adds up to roughly 72 gallons a day. That's more than 2,000 gallons for a whole month.

One commenter advised: "Turn water off, replace fill valve and throw a flapper in while you're doing it. Will total like 15-20 bucks, and take 15 minutes."

Another noted the specific toilet model could matter and that the easiest repair may depend on the hardware already in place: "That's a Mansfield. They'd have to replace the entire flush valve to use a new flapper. It probably just needs a new seal."

More background

A refill that only kicks on every couple of minutes can still waste a meaningful amount of water without attracting much attention. 

That makes a $15 to $20 repair suggestion stand out. Compared with a high bill caused by more than 70 gallons of daily water loss, a quick, inexpensive fix is much easier to deal with.

Thousands of lost gallons in a month can also affect more than a household budget. Water has to be pumped, treated, and delivered through systems that use energy and infrastructure, so fixing a toilet leak can reduce waste without requiring a major home upgrade.

Where can I learn more?

These stories include simple ways to test for tank leaks and low-cost fixes involving flappers, seals, and fill valves.

• A handyman showed how a simple flapper-valve fix stopped a constantly running toilet.

• A plumber used a simple toilet dye test to trace a sky-high bill.

• A home maintenance expert showed how food coloring in the tank can reveal leaks.

• A plumber shared how a quick DIY toilet repair can prevent wasted water.

• A handyman broke down an easy toilet repair to avoid an unnecessary plumber visit.

Get TCD's free newsletters for easy tips, smart advice, and a chance to earn $5,000 toward home upgrades. To see more stories like this one, change your Google preferences here.

Cool Divider