A Property Owners Association (POA) threatened to auction off a homeowner's house if $655 isn't paid in 90 days.
The Tennessee homeowner says the dispute over unpaid dues holds no legal basis because community covenants describe payments as voluntary.
Here's what to know
The English Mountain Property Owners Association sent a September 1 letter warning residents with unpaid assessments that their properties could face liens, according to WATE. The community sits in the northeastern foothills of the Great Smoky Mountains in Sevier County.
Homeowner Martin Sims said, "We owe them $655, and if we don't pay it, they're going to put a lien on our property and auction it off in 90 days."
The association's letter stated: "If you do not pay the full past-due balance, the English Mountain POA will place a lien against your property."
WATE reported that the association has no clubhouse, swimming pool, or public grounds. The POA was formed to help with road upkeep in the development.
The development dates back more than 50 years.
More background
Homeowner Bill Johnson said he stopped paying after asking for repairs to Glasgow Street and was told that would never happen. Over 25 years of owning an English Mountain home, he had voluntarily contributed nearly $2,000 toward road work.
"People on the board told me they will never fix Glasgow. So, I refuse to pay," Johnson said. "I will not pay dues."
The disagreement over the association's authority goes back years. In 2021, property owners' legal counsel determined that the association could not mandate dues. An attorney representing the association reached the opposite conclusion in 2022, writing that it could levy assessments.
This is not a one-off case. HOAs across the country have been caught blocking money-saving home updates, including rooftop solar panels and native plant lawns.
What's being done?
An attorney asked the association's board to document its authority to place liens on homes or auction them off. The request came in a September 15 cease-and-desist letter sent on behalf of a homeowner who had not paid assessments.
WATE reported that the board used its bylaws to impose mandatory assessments in 2024, but its attempt to change the covenants failed. Covenants set property-use restrictions and take precedence over bylaws, which govern internal board operations.
The original covenants contained no requirement to pay assessments, according to a copy retained by former board member Hugh Vaughn. At the time of WATE's report, no liens had been added to the titles of homeowners who had withheld payment.
For homeowners navigating association rules, the TCD Guide offers a resource on working with HOAs.
Homeowner Fiona Vaughn said the dispute centers on whether residents still have the choice described in those original rules.
"It was always your choice. Now the board is saying we don't have the choice anymore, that dues have always been mandatory."
Where can I learn more?
Homeowners elsewhere have also faced threats to their homes over unpaid association dues.
• An Arizona homeowner lost his $475,000 home over a $977 HOA debt.
• In Florida, unpaid country club dues topped $100,000, putting a home at risk.
• Colorado's Blackstone homeowners say country club dues doubled, with no option to opt out.
• In Texas, a homeowner says a no-amenity HOA charges $3,000 annually, plus hand-delivery fees.
• In New Mexico, an HOA faces 24 delinquent accounts and $1,000 collection fees.
Get TCD's free newsletters for easy tips, smart advice, and a chance to earn $5,000 toward home upgrades. To see more stories like this one, change your Google preferences here.







