One shopper's list of new clothing purchases since 2018 consisted of just two underwear multipacks and two pairs of black ankle socks.
But when they asked other shoppers which items should always be bought new, commenters pointed to safety as a crucial consideration.
Here's what to know
In a post on Reddit's r/Anticonsumption community, the shopper asked which goods, beyond socks and underwear, people believed should be purchased brand-new. The question followed their observations of thrift stores filled with dishware, glass jars, Halloween costumes, and children's toys.
"I've gotten to the point where it's very hard for me to think of any material goods that I need to buy brand-new and not used," the original poster wrote.
One commenter listed menstrual cups, razors, and toothbrushes, while another noted that medical supplies, such as needles, should be new and sealed. The OP agreed with both.
"Anything safety related — helmets, car seats, crib mattresses, etc., because you don't know their histories," one commenter wrote.
More background
The OP also playfully asked which products readers would stop manufacturing if there were no consequences. Their frustration stemmed from shopping in stores whose shelves reminded them of ongoing production despite the abundance of existing goods.
One commenter blamed advertising for encouraging people to want more possessions and proposed getting rid of it.
The OP contrasted the large billboards and screen ads they were used to in the United States with the less pervasive advertising they noticed on a trip to Norway.
Another commenter said comfort and condition led them to favor new shoes, sheets, towels, and bathing suits over used ones. They also reported finding thrift-store prices higher than those for new goods.
What can be done?
A 65-year-old commenter said their wardrobe was almost entirely secondhand, except for items such as Costco base layers, underwear, and socks. They started shopping for clothes at thrift stores when they were 17.
They got most of their own furnishings from thrift stores or Marketplace and professionally refinished Danish furniture. Their work on older dining sets included refinishing and replacing the upholstery.
"It's amazing how good a tired old '60s dining set looks after a full refinish and new upholstery," they wrote.
The OP said they would readily accept a sister's used towels and sheets — items that might feel less comfortable to take from a stranger. They pointed to family hand-me-downs as another way to get goods secondhand.
Meanwhile, the commenter who raised personal hygiene products said effectiveness remains a priority when they look for options with a low environmental impact.
Get TCD's free newsletters for easy tips, smart advice, and a chance to earn $5,000 toward home upgrades. To see more stories like this one, change your Google preferences here.







