After a plumber installed a recirculating pump, one homeowner still without reliable hot water took to Reddit's r/AskPlumbing forum to ask whether the water heater setup looked configured correctly.
Here's what to know
In the Reddit thread, after sharing an image of the install, the original poster wrote, "I questioned if it would work and he assured me it will. They did this for free as an add-on to my new build after close because it takes forever for us to get hot water to the faucets."
OP bluntly asked the plumbing community, "Will this recirculating pump actually work?"

Commenters flooded the thread to let the homeowner know it wasn't set up correctly. Many said an apparent bypass, a straight pipe beside the pump, lacked a shutoff valve.
One of the top comments read, "It's missing at least 1 ball valve. You'll want to close the valve on the bypass line if the pump is running. As-is this will pump water around in a loop." Another user added, "This is the equivalent of a 'short' on an electrical line."
A third commenter wrote, "I've been staring at this photo for like 10 minutes trying to think what the person's thought process was putting this in… I got nothing." One user warned, "There are also no check valves. This pump will burn itself out."
The homeowner later updated their post to report that they "ran an extension cord because I had to know. As you all thought, it doesn't do anything."
What can be done?
For households also considering a water-heater replacement, Cala offers configurable smart heat pump water heaters. Matching water-heating schedules to household demand can help reduce energy use and bills by planning heating around when hot water is needed. Configurable controls from Cala give homeowners a way to align water heating with those needs.
Because heat pump water heaters move heat into water rather than relying solely on electric resistance heating, their lower electricity demand can help reduce household energy costs.
Get TCD's free newsletters for easy tips, smart advice, and a chance to earn $5,000 toward home upgrades. To see more stories like this one, change your Google preferences here.




