• Home Home

Trenching for sewer line repair puts Pennsylvania homeowner's property at risk: '[It's] all gone'

"When I asked about doing it without digging the guy kind of shrugged and said it depends."

A trench for a black sewer line.

Photo Credit: iStock

A Pennsylvania homeowner wanted to repair a sewer line without sacrificing their lawn, walkway, or young maple tree. Their plumber's proposal called for digging a trench across the entire front yard.

Hoping to find a less destructive option, they turned to fellow homeowners for advice.

Here's what to know

The roughly 50-foot sewer line connecting the Central Pennsylvania home to the street was believed to be old clay pipe, according to the homeowner's Reddit post on r/HomeImprovement. A camera inspection had revealed cracks and roots inside it.

The plumber had proposed a full-length trench, but the contractor offered little explanation about whether excavation could be avoided.

"When I asked about doing it without digging the guy kind of shrugged and said it depends," the original poster wrote. "It depends on what?"

"My lawn, the walkway, and the little maple I planted when we moved in, all GONE," the homeowner shared.

Ultimately, the OP wanted additional opinions on the least intrusive method to replace the aging pipe. The homeowner asked, "Is my line a candidate for pipe bursting, or is there something about it that means they have to dig?"

More background

Pipe bursting is a method of trenchless sewer rehabilitation. According to the U.S. EPA, this involves a hydraulic "bursting" tool getting pulled through the existing piping, opening and forcing the old pipe outward to create space for the new pipe, and pulling the new pipe into the now-open cavity.

"Your case sounds like exactly what pipe bursting is for," one person in the comments wrote. "We had multiple quotes for a similar situation — the cheapest was basically a guy with a backhoe that would trench it, but we went with pipe bursting to preserve the lawn and sidewalk. It worked great."

Another commenter recommended getting an independent inspection before agreeing to repairs. They had declined the proposed work because they could not afford it and said the line had no further leaks or clogs over the following 10 years. They cautioned, "Take this with a grain of salt."

A different homeowner's $25,000 repair bill offered a more cautionary example. Their displaced clay pipes had leaked into the surrounding ground, creating a sinkhole that affected the house. They, too, recommended a second opinion if the original poster was unsure.

"Clay pipes [weren't] even joined together very well. They have gone away with them so long ago. They were literally just smashed together hoping they would stay put. The ground moves over time so pieces have probably come undone," the same commenter explained. "That's what happened to me and I didn't know it."

Some commenters in the Reddit thread were more concerned with the proximity of the original poster's maple tree to the pipe than anything else. 

"The maple tree directly over the sewer line has to go no matter what," one cautioned. 

"Well, you should remove the maple regardless," another commenter warned. "Trees and pipes don't mix well; even pipes that don't carry water can be strained or damaged by tree roots causing shifting."

What can be done?

The camera footage could help a trenchless repair contractor assess whether the line was intact enough for pipe bursting, one commenter noted. They recommended requesting the video for that review, explaining that significant sagging or a collapse could rule out the method.

Another suggested contacting local companies experienced in both pipe bursting and cured-in-place pipe, or CIPP. A separate commenter noted that pipe bursting might be beyond the original plumber's capabilities or require tools they did not have, offering another reason to consult someone familiar with those methods.

Get TCD's free newsletters for easy tips, smart advice, and a chance to earn $5,000 toward home upgrades. To see more stories like this one, change your Google preferences here.

Cool Divider