The buyers of a $1.41 million Nantucket home won a $1.28 million jury award in a dispute over whether they could expand it. They said their real estate agent had assured them an addition was possible, but a deed restriction prohibited it.
Here's what to know
Dr. Mary Murray, an obstetrician, and Jeff Ment, a lawyer, purchased the two-bedroom, 1,200-square-foot home at 151 Polpis Road in 2020, according to Realtor.com.
The Westport, Connecticut, couple hoped to use the property as a summer home for themselves and their six children.
Their agent, Melanie Gowen of a Nantucket real estate brokerage, had previously helped them find rentals. According to Murray's account, Gowen said the island's building officials had verified that they could double the home's size.
Murray said Gowen also sketched an addition and sent a video of the proposed project.
The couple contacted officials in early 2021 about enlarging the home and upgrading its septic system. However, the town told them a deed restriction barred any expansion.
"That's when everything started to crystallize that it wasn't quite as advertised," Ment told Realtor.com.
More background
The couple's June 2021 lawsuit accused Gowen and her brokerage of misrepresentation, negligence, and violations of Massachusetts consumer protection law, among other claims.
Neither a proposed property trade nor a later suggestion of a brokerage-funded bridge loan materialized, the couple said. Gowen's colleague Kenny Hilbig raised both ideas as they tried, unsuccessfully, to settle outside court.
Ment said they hired a lawyer to close the transaction but did not ask that lawyer to determine whether they could expand the home. They believed Gowen had already confirmed that possibility with the building department.
The couple said in their lawsuit that they trusted Gowen enough to buy the home because of their longstanding relationship and her claimed experience as an island homebuilder, interior designer, and property developer.
A jury awarded them $1.28 million, and a Superior Court judge let both the decision and damages stand, according to Realtor.com. The defendants appealed.
The brokerage's lawyer, Ray Cashen, disputed the outcome in an email to Realtor.com. He said the buyers had received the restrictive document 11 days before closing and had two lawyers review it. He also said they knew about a two-bedroom septic restriction and later sold the home at a profit.
According to Realtor.com, the couple sold the property for $1.95 million in 2021 before spending $3.1 million on an island home with five bedrooms.
Murray said, however, that the second purchase left them with more debt because they financed it through home equity borrowing and loans against their 401(k) accounts.
"I always tell my patients, you should get a second opinion," Murray said. "If you're not sure about what I tell you, please get a second opinion. I want you to feel really confident. Really, it's the same with this."
Get TCD's free newsletters for easy tips, smart advice, and a chance to earn $5,000 toward home upgrades. To see more stories like this one, change your Google preferences here.







