• Home Home

After Idaho's June storm, one Allstate family says every roof on the block got fixed except theirs

The storm cracked tiles and left shingle debris piled up in their backyard.

A home with storm damage.

Photo Credit: iStock

After a June storm damaged roofs in one Idaho neighborhood, about 10 homeowners completed repairs, according to Idaho TV station KTVB. But the Corrales family says it was the exception, with their insurance company denying their claim.

Here's what to know

As extreme weather events have grown more severe, more homeowners have experienced property damage from everything from wildfires to hurricanes to hailstorms. Meanwhile, insurance premiums across the U.S. have increased considerably. 

When an intense hailstorm struck their neighborhood, the Corrales family home was one of several damaged roofs. The storm cracked tiles and left shingle debris piled up in their backyard. 

While many of their neighbors received approvals from their insurance companies and had new roofs paid for, the Corrales family found themselves in a different situation. Their carrier, Allstate, denied their claim, according to KTVB. 

When KTVB reached out to Allstate, the insurer responded only, "We are supporting our customer with their claim and will resolve it according to their policy." 

During its investigation, KTVB spoke with several neighboring homeowners who confirmed their insurance companies paid for roof replacements after the storm.

What can be done to prevent similar situations? 

While it remains to be seen whether Allstate will ultimately pay for the Corrales family to replace their damaged roof, their situation highlights the importance of reading the fine print and understanding the nuances of what your insurance covers and, just as importantly, what it does not. 

Where can I learn more?

The Corrales family's dispute echoes battles other homeowners have faced with insurers over roof repairs after extreme weather. These stories cover dropped policies, alleged insurer misconduct, market instability, and fights for stronger roofs.

• In Iowa, homeowners saw policy renewals dropped as climate disasters strained insurers.

• In Florida, outrageous revelations against insurance companies sparked demands for answers from homeowners.

• After Hurricane Helene, threats to their property spread into an insurance crunch across Florida.

• Officials across disaster-prone states pleaded with insurers to maintain coverage for homes as disasters intensified.

• Homeowners fought an HOA to install a hurricane-proof roof after storm fears grew.

Get TCD's free newsletters for easy tips, smart advice, and a chance to earn $5,000 toward home upgrades. To see more stories like this one, change your Google preferences here.

Cool Divider