A Texas resident vented on Reddit that they pay about $3,000 per year to a homeowners association that offers no neighborhood amenities in return — not even trash pickup.
Here's what to know
In r/FirstTimeHomeBuyer, the homeowner said their HOA provides "literally nothing" even though it collects thousands every year, mostly linked to "service inspection fees," grass cutting, and violations over "the occasional weed growing on my sidewalk."
Other charges they found questionable included a $125 fee for hand-delivered notices and a $25 "association fee" that shows up every time they clear their balance.
"Why did we let them have this much power?" they asked.
Several commenters urged the homeowner to dig deeper into the finances.
"I'd definitely look at the budget to see where the money is, where it's going. Is there a seawall? Do you have to pay [for] dune maintenance?" one person advised.
TCD Picks » Quince Spotlight
💡These best-sellers from Quince deliver affordable, sustainable luxury for all
"It's your right to get ahold of the budget. It might take some time, but you can see exactly where that money is going," another said.
More background
When another user was optimistic the newer, 150-house subdivision might eventually add features like a clubhouse, pool, or tennis courts, the original poster pushed back, saying, "We will never get amenities," and noting that the development was surrounded by natural protected areas.
"Our roads are public and maintained by the city," the OP continued.
That made the $3K in fees all the more baffling, and many homeowners can relate. Across the country, HOAs have faced backlash not only over dues and fines but also over rules that can block money-saving home upgrades, including rooftop solar panels and native plant lawns.
What can be done?
Commenters told the homeowner to review the budget and compare what the governing documents actually allow with the fees being charged.
According to the OP, they've already started doing the math. "I've looked at the budget. I am actively participating in our meetings. It doesn't add up," they said, noting that they pay $600 annually for hand-delivered notices that could be mailed at a significantly lower price.
For homeowners dealing with restrictive bylaws or fee disputes, working with HOAs can help clarify how rules are set and what it takes to challenge them.
In this case, many argued for a more hands-on role. "Run for office and change it," one said.
Where can I learn more?
Questions about HOA fees and what homeowners get in return come up again and again.
• Residents demanded an investigation into amenity fees for features they said do not exist.
• On Reddit, one homeowner sought help after overreaching HOA threats sparked outrage.
• Another resident blasted vague HOA requirements after years of steep maintenance fees.
• A condo owner argued the board had no grounds to block an EV charger.
• Residents put an HOA on blast after it eliminated bike storage.
Get TCD's free newsletters for easy tips, smart advice, and a chance to earn $5,000 toward home upgrades. To see more stories like this one, change your Google preferences here.
