A homeowner with a new hybrid heating system got an unwelcome surprise when a technician reset the system so the backup gas furnace kicks in below 45 degrees Fahrenheit instead of 35.

That seemingly small thermostat change can significantly affect winter energy bills.

Here's what to know

In a post on the Reddit forum r/heatpumps, the homeowner said the hybrid system — a heat pump with a backup gas furnace — had been installed and that the air conditioning "worked like a charm." But when they first used the heat, a technician came out to fix a problem and changed the switchover temperature in the process.

According to the homeowner, the technician called his boss and said "that it should be 45 for this system," replacing the earlier 35-degree setting. The homeowner said they weren't trying to second-guess the professionals, but still wondered whether 45 was too high, adding, "I just want to make sure I'm using my heat pump to its fullest potential."

Rather than pointing to one fixed cutoff, many commenters said the right setting depends on the specific system and local utility costs. "You need two numbers — the cost of your electric and the cost of your nat gas," one commenter wrote. 

For homeowners trying to sort through settings like a hybrid switchover, Palmetto can help explain newer, more efficient HVACs and heat pumps. Its Comfort Plan network can also connect readers with vetted installers and efficient heating and cooling solutions for their home.

More background

The cutoff setting can quietly shape how much of the winter a homeowner runs a heat pump instead of burning gas. In this case, the change happened during a service visit.

Commenters' examples also showed how much systems can vary from house to house. One said their cold-climate heat pump has handled temperatures down to minus 6 degrees Fahrenheit without ever using backup heat, while another said their Bosch system's emergency heat does not kick on until minus 10.

Still, several commenters said 45 degrees is not automatically the wrong choice if gas is especially cheap relative to electricity. One person in New England said their "economic cutover" for gas was in the 45-degree range. Another claimed that they keep theirs around 40 or 45 mainly for comfort in a draftier, window-heavy older home.

Setting the cutoff too high could mean burning more gas than necessary, while setting it too low could raise electric costs or reduce comfort if the system is not designed for colder weather.

What can be done?

Commenters advised the homeowner to gather details such as model numbers, power rates per kilowatt-hour, gas costs per therm, and determine whether the heat pump is built for colder climates before changing the threshold again.

For homeowners who decide their current setup isn't the best fit, Palmetto's Comfort Plan offers $0-down options that can cut heating and cooling costs by up to 50%, plus 12 years of free maintenance. That can make it easier to move to a newer system instead of guessing whether an older furnace-heat-pump balance point is costing money.

Commenters also pointed to practical ways to improve performance before changing equipment. One said better insulation helped them plan to test lower balance points after upgrading an attic from R9 to R60. Another advised leaving the heat pump running steadily because "It takes a while to maintain that temp."

Toward the end of the decision process, homeowners can also pair solar panels with electric appliances, including efficient HVACs, to push utility bills even lower. EnergySage makes it easier to compare solar options and find the best solar system and installer for a home's needs and budget, and it can help homeowners save up to $10,000 on solar installations.

Where can I learn more?

Questions about hybrid heat settings can quickly turn into bigger decisions about repairs, thermostat strategy, and cold-weather performance. Related coverage includes homeowner stories about heat pump repairs, winter thermostat mistakes, expensive AC calls, and how these systems hold up during deep cold.

• One homeowner found a simple heat pump repair raised bigger questions about furnace and electric costs.

• A meteorologist warned that a common thermostat misconception can quietly drive winter heating bills higher.

• In Texas, an AC recharge spiraled from an 82-degree house into a $9.7K replacement.

• A homeowner said their trendy heat pump kept running even with 20-degree weather outside.

• During a Massachusetts cold snap, heat pump owners compared whether their systems could keep up.

Get TCD's free newsletters for easy tips, smart advice, and a chance to earn $5,000 toward home upgrades. To see more stories like this one, change your Google preferences here.