A homeowner was left questioning whom to trust after a "free" furnace inspection resulted in a red-tag gas-leak warning that their utility company later dismissed.
Here's what to know
The homeowner shared their dilemma on Reddit in r/HVACAdvice, writing that a local home-service company with thousands of online reviews had given their family's 18-year-old furnace a "free" inspection.
The company, which the homeowner said they had used before, had more than 11,000 Google reviews. When the technician arrived, they informed the original poster that the furnace was experiencing a gas leak, placing a red tag on the appliance to indicate it should not be used. However, the technician suspiciously did not shut off the gas despite the alleged leak.
"I felt weird about the situation, so called the emergency number for my gas utility company," the OP explained.
When their utility company did its own inspection, it didn't detect a leak either. The utility worker even went so far as to remove the red tag from the OP's furnace.
Unsure what to do next, the OP turned to Reddit for advice as to whether they should get a third opinion or contact the first company to call them out for their apparent misdiagnosis.
For homeowners considering an HVAC upgrade, Palmetto helps compare efficient HVAC and heat-pump options while connecting people with vetted installers through its Comfort Plan network.
What commenters said
Redditors generally expressed skepticism about the first company's inspection and thought the utility worker was more trustworthy.
"Utility cleared the tag, so you're safe," chimed in one Redditor. "Stay away from original companies."
"Red tag for a gas leak but left the gas on?" added another. "That right there tells me there was no leak, they just wanted to make a sale."
Some Redditors cautioned that unscrupulous companies often use "free" or low-cost inspections as loss leaders aimed at getting customers to pay for expensive equipment and services.
"They need to earn that money one way or another," advised a commenter identified as an approved technician. "Better to pay someone with a higher door knocker price, odds are they are less incentivized to make a larger ticket using alternate methods."
When an HVAC replacement is actually necessary, upgrading to energy-efficient, electric heating and cooling can help manage utility expenses and reduce spending on fluctuating fuel prices. Palmetto's Comfort Plan includes $0-down options that can potentially provide heating and cooling savings of up to 50%. Palmetto Comfort Plans also offer 12 years of free maintenance.
For homeowners exploring efficient electric HVAC, pairing it with solar can further help manage utility spending and increase household energy independence. EasyHome offers a solar shopping tool to help homeowners compare installation offers and find the best deal.
Where can I learn more?
Other homeowners have also questioned furnace safety warnings and recommendations to replace their equipment.
• In Canada, free furnace checks often were the first step in costly HVAC scams.
• A homeowner's 1997 furnace was deemed unsafe to run during a free inspection.
• A Philadelphia homeowner received a $4,900 furnace quote after carbon monoxide testing raised concerns.
• In Pennsylvania, technicians flagged a flexible gas line after a furnace was called code-compliant.
• A homeowner's rusty furnace bolt prompted a $14,000 replacement pitch others questioned.
Get TCD's free newsletters for easy tips, smart advice, and a chance to earn $5,000 toward home upgrades. To see more stories like this one, change your Google preferences here.




