• Home Home

Chicago renter demands answers after utility bills more than double under building's new payment system

"The tenant's bill is not tied to actual tenant usage."

A woman opens her mouth in shock while examining an energy bill while sitting on a couch.

Photo Credit: iStock

A Chicago renter who once budgeted $100 a month for utilities has seen her bills more than double after her building changed its billing system, leaving her questioning how the charges were calculated.

Here's what to know

After an ownership change in 2024, management replaced the flat utility fee at renter Maiko Lehman's building with a ratio utility billing system, or RUBS, according to WBEZ. Lehman moved into her two-bedroom apartment in Chicago's Edgewater neighborhood in 2022.

Under the new system, Lehman's bills have fluctuated wildly, with monthly charges ranging from $88.05 to $225.57. To determine a resident's utility charge, a third-party billing company has been using apartment size, occupancy, and other factors to allocate the building's master gas, sewer, and water bills among tenants. The billing company then has been adding a service fee on top. 

Lehman worried residents have been paying for maintenance problems, including leaky toilets and drafty windows, that management has not fixed, WBEZ reported. Her requests to see the formula used to calculate the residents' charges have gone unanswered.

When WBEZ reached out to Lehman's property manager for comment, the news outlet received no response. Residents and advocates have objected to the billing practices as being unfair. 

"The tenant's bill is not tied to actual tenant usage," said Olivia Wein, a senior attorney for the National Consumer Law Center, per WBEZ.

More background

Chicago's Department of Housing and Department of Buildings have not been tracking RUBS adoption, but consumer advocates and tenant organizations warned that such systems were becoming more common in buildings without separate meters for each apartment, WBEZ reported.

Illinois has not passed a law banning RUBS, and, according to Wein, no agency has been tasked with regulating the billing companies. The Illinois Commerce Commission told WBEZ that ratio metering falls outside its authority, describing it as a landlord-tenant matter.

The Illinois Apartment Association defended transparent, consistent formulas as a way to encourage conservation and ease upward pressure on rent.

Lehman has not been the only resident impacted by the change. Viola Davis, an 85-year-old resident of Oglesby Towers in South Shore, previously paid a $105 flat fee. After the switch, her monthly charges varied between roughly $150 and over $220, WBEZ reported.

Davis said the uncertainty strains her pension and Social Security budget, affecting whether she can afford groceries or birthday money for her great-grandson, per WBEZ. Davis also found that some neighbors had bills reaching $500.

What's being done?

To fight back against the new billing system, Davis and her neighbors contacted Southside Together, an organizing nonprofit, and formed a tenant union. Their efforts persuaded management to reverse a trash fee, according to housing organizer Savannah Brown, as cited by WBEZ. Following the victory, the group has continued to press for an end to RUBS.

Illinois already requires landlords to notify tenants before switching to RUBS and gives renters the right to inspect master utility bills. Chicago Mayor Brandon Johnson's proposed Protecting Renters Ordinance would codify some of those protections locally.

Chicago residents have not been the only ones pushing back against RUBS. Wein pointed to Connecticut's ban and efforts to prohibit RUBS in Seattle and Los Angeles as other examples of a growing movement against the practice. 

On top of passing along opaque and expensive utility charges, landlords and HOAs across the country have also prevented residents from adopting money-saving practices such as gardening and hanging clotheslines to dry laundry. For residents seeking changes to property rules, the TCD Guide's resource on working with HOAs offers approaches that can be used when dealing with both homeowners associations and landlords. 

For some tenants, the higher utility bills have threatened their ability to stay in their home. At Oglesby Towers, resident Antoinette Gray, 63, faced eviction because she could not keep up with the bills.

"When Stuart Handler started RUBS, it had a real impact on me, my life, everything," she said, per WBEZ. "I've done the best I could to stay here. Their response has been, 'If you can't pay, just leave.'"

Get TCD's free newsletters for easy tips, smart advice, and a chance to earn $5,000 toward home upgrades. To see more stories like this one, change your Google preferences here.

Cool Divider