• Home Home

California condo owner wants answers as HOA makes decisions behind closed doors

"It's about time the Legislature forces HOA boards to shine a light on what they are doing."

A row of residential buildings with gardens and trees in front.

Photo Credit: iStock

Homeowners association fees keep climbing, but many residents say they still don't know where the money goes.

A downtown San Diego condo owner is calling for greater transparency from HOAs as rising assessments leave him with unanswered questions about his own investment in the building.

Here's what to know

In a CalMatters commentary, William Fulton, who teaches at the University of California, San Diego and also owns a condo in the building, urged lawmakers to strengthen disclosure requirements under the Davis-Stirling Act, California's law governing HOAs.

The complaint centers on how little residents get to see: budget decisions, contracts, and other calls that shape their stake in the building. Residents' assessments pay for common areas, janitorial work, a 24-hour concierge, and two full-time engineers.

"Our board meets almost exclusively in closed session, communicates with us mostly via email, delivers a budget to us with an increased assessment each year without much explanation, and provides information mostly through carefully curated town halls rather than real board meetings," Fulton wrote.

Boards are not required to notify members about litigation involving their association, whether it brings the case or is sued, the commentary noted.

More background

Under Davis-Stirling, boards can go behind closed doors only for a short list of topics: litigation, personnel matters, and what the law calls contract "formation."

Fulton argued, however, that the contract provision gives boards leeway to discuss association business privately because HOAs rely on outside companies for many services.

Enforcing the rules can mean suing an organization that residents both belong to and help finance, Fulton argued. The commentary said associations face weaker oversight than local governments, even though both provide services residents depend on.

HOAs can also prevent homeowners from making money-saving updates, such as adding rooftop solar panels or installing native plant lawns.

What's being done?

California Assemblymember Joe Patterson backed Assembly Bill 1184, which would have pushed HOA boards to open up more of their records to residents. Among its requirements, the commentary noted, boards would have had to disclose any lawsuits discussed behind closed doors.

Fulton called for passage if Patterson reintroduces the bill, which failed to advance before the legislative session ended.

After he learned that the property manager had been handing out contract details only to people who specifically asked, several residents pushed for wider access. Management then added the contracts to the building's website.

Davis-Stirling allows homeowners to request contracts and other association records, according to the commentary. For residents navigating restrictions or seeking changes to association rules, working with an HOA is one starting point.

For Fulton, however, access to individual documents is only part of the solution.

"It's about time the Legislature forces HOA boards to shine a light on what they are doing," he wrote.

Where can I learn more?

For condo owners facing higher assessments, knowing how their HOA spends its money is important.

• California condo owners could face higher HOA reserve contributions under a 30-year funding bill.

• California legislation could raise HOA fees for millions of homeowners if signed into law.

• A California condo owner took out a loan after facing $44,000 in HOA assessments.

• Condo residents facing five new assessments say years of low HOA dues caused them.

• In California's Coachella Valley, condos carry monthly HOA fees reaching $1,887.

Get TCD's free newsletters for easy tips, smart advice, and a chance to earn $5,000 toward home upgrades. To see more stories like this one, change your Google preferences here.

Cool Divider