• Home Home

Arkansas buyers walk away after siding repairs alone are estimated at $50,000

"There is no way you can get to the bottom of this and get accurate bids within a week."

Siding on a house.

Photo Credit: Reddit

An Arkansas couple decided to walk away from a home purchase after a contractor estimated roughly $50,000 in siding repairs.

Here's what to know

The buyer turned to Reddit's r/FirstTimeHomeBuyer for help assessing the damage, estimating repair costs, and deciding whether to proceed. They had about a week remaining on the inspection contingency for a two-story house built in 1985 in central Arkansas.

Siding on a house.
Photo Credit: Reddit
A brick chimney.
Photo Credit: Reddit

A piece of the home's original hardboard siding crumbled in the buyer's hand. Replacement siding covered the lower portion of the house, but the original siding had wavy upper boards, swollen sections, and gaps near a brick chimney.

"We knew the siding needed some work, so we offered with an inspection contingency to get it checked properly. Then the inspection turned up a freshly painted ceiling that's still wet, and the more we've looked since, the worse it's gotten. That's what the contingency is there for, I guess. Plus once I found the semi hidden attic door," the original poster explained.

More background

Storm damage had already led to a roof replacement in 2023, but the OP described several other areas with signs of possible moisture problems.

They saw black mildew in the window tracks along with gaps and cracked caulk around several frames. Beside a bedroom window, the drywall showed bubbling and staining.

Dark, mold-like spots surrounded a gable vent in the attic. The OP also reported a stained, deteriorating board at the base of an exterior wall with drip streaks on the wall. They later said the inspector had overlooked that area, which was behind a semi-hidden attic door.

The inspector's moisture meter registered moisture in the kitchen ceiling below an upstairs bathroom.

The seller had reported no history of mold or water problems in the disclosure.

What can be done?

The OP contacted siding professionals and received a roughly $50,000 estimate from a contractor who reviewed photos. That contractor thought the house likely needed a full siding tear-off and replacement sheathing.

Commenters overwhelmingly urged the OP to walk away.

"I rarely say walk. Very little scares me. This is a hard no, friend. There is no way you can get to the bottom of this and get accurate bids within a week," one person warned.

The siding expense, water damage, and suspected mold led the OP and their wife to abandon the purchase after receiving the contractor's assessment.

Where can I learn more?

Siding damage and moisture problems have left other people weighing whether to go through with a purchase.

• An inspector flagged loose siding, missing sealant, and a settling driveway at a $440,000 home.

• A first-time buyer faced roof, HVAC, mold, and sewer problems, prompting advice to walk away.

• A buyer under contract on a Southeast ranch discovered basement mold before closing.

Get TCD's free newsletters for easy tips, smart advice, and a chance to earn $5,000 toward home upgrades. To see more stories like this one, change your Google preferences here.

Cool Divider