A homeowner facing a broken furnace turned to Reddit for advice after their warranty company offered a choice: repair the equipment or accept $1,429 toward a replacement.
Here's what to know
The problem was a failed control board in a furnace installed in October 2007, according to the homeowner's post on Reddit's r/HVACAdvice. The home warranty company offered a cash settlement toward a new furnace and installation as an alternative to replacing the board.
"Would you recommend replacing the furnace now rather than waiting for another component to fail?" the homeowner asked.
The homeowner said the heat exchanger had about a year of warranty coverage remaining. A technician had also told them the inducer motor was wearing out.
For homeowners exploring HVAC equipment replacement, Palmetto helps compare efficient HVAC and heat pump solutions and connect with vetted installers through its Comfort Plan network.
More background
One commenter warned that replacing the heat exchanger could be expensive when it came to the labor, even while it remained under warranty, and asked whether the homeowner could afford or finance a new furnace.
"I am not the original owner. I know the previous owner well," the homeowner explained when asked. A commenter explained that subsequent owners did not retain the lifetime unit replacement warranty available to the original owner.
Commenters disagreed about the durability of the manufacturer's heat exchangers: One reported recurring failures, while another shared a positive experience. Still, several were in favor of replacing the furnace.
"I'm an HVAC guy and a homeowner. Time to retire the furnace," wrote one person. Another added, "That furnace was worth $1,400 when it was brand new. Replace the whole thing."
What can be done?
Homeowners evaluating replacement costs may also consider how efficient heating and cooling can help manage energy expenses and exposure to higher energy prices. Palmetto's Comfort Plan offers $0-down options and offers potential heating and cooling cost savings of up to 50%. Palmetto Comfort Plans also offer 12 years of free maintenance.
For homeowners choosing efficient electric HVAC equipment, pairing it with solar can further manage utility spending and increase a household's energy self-reliance. EasyHome's solar comparison shopping tool helps homeowners view installation offers side by side to find the best deal.
"Absolutely take that settlement offer and put it right towards a new furnace. Nineteen years is a good life for the equipment; time for replacement," another commenter said.
Get TCD's free newsletters for easy tips, smart advice, and a chance to earn $5,000 toward home upgrades. To see more stories like this one, change your Google preferences here.




