A Reddit user looking for a replacement mower for their 95-year-old father-in-law — who still insists on mowing his own yard and refuses to hire a lawn service — sparked a conversation about whether gas power is still the best option for older adults who want to keep caring for their own yards.
Here's what to know
In a Reddit post, they said their father-in-law "needs a new mower that is self propelled, has a bagger, and is gas powered. He wants an 18 inch model but the only one I can find is Powersmart and reviews are not good. Does anyone have any suggestions?"
Although the post asked about lightweight gas models, several commenters questioned the fuel choice instead of focusing on brands.
"Battery mowers are lighter, are quieter, and require less maintenance," one wrote.
"Can't imagine a 95 year old pulling the cord to start a gas engine mower," another added. "Agree - battery mower is the way to go - just push a button."
The original poster made clear that the issue was also about independence and personal preference, replying, "He's an amazing guy and broke the pull cord on his current gas mower. And when a 95 yo wants gas power you don't argue."
TCD Picks » Quince Spotlight
💡These best-sellers from Quince deliver affordable, sustainable luxury for all
Commenters did name a few gas options, including the Stihl 453v, used Honda HRX217 mowers, and older Craftsman models. At the same time, multiple people noted that finding an 18-inch gas mower is difficult.
More background
Battery mowers kept resurfacing as the practical alternative. One commenter suggested a test approach: "Get the battery self propelled and ask him to try it once. It's lighter and a lot easier to start. You can always return it." Others emphasized benefits that could reduce costs over time too, such as not having to buy fuel, change engine oil, or keep up with as much small-engine maintenance.
Some pushback also focused on what is actually sold now. Commenters repeatedly described 18 inches as "a very odd size," saying most walk-behind mowers are now 20 or 21 inches and that many newer offerings are built around battery systems instead of gas.
An Echo owner in the thread said a battery setup ran "$600 or so for the mower, charger, and two packs," and added that the same batteries can be used with trimmers and blowers, potentially stretching the value of the purchase across other yard tools.
What can be done?
Commenters largely focused on testing a battery self-propelled mower before committing to another gas machine. The suggestion respected the father-in-law's desire to keep mowing while addressing the two clearest pain points in the thread — weight and starting effort.
"Find someone with an Ego push mower and let him try it a couple times. He might just fall in love," one commenter wrote.
For older homeowners who want to stay active in yard work, a side-by-side test can show whether a switch would make mowing easier without sacrificing independence.
Get TCD's free newsletters for easy tips, smart advice, and a chance to earn $5,000 toward home upgrades. To see more stories like this one, change your Google preferences here.
