A townhome owner was still getting hot showers without trouble when their neighbor's water heater burst, prompting them to consider replacing their own aging tank.
Their Bradford White unit had reached its 12th year, raising concerns about how much longer it would last. The resident then shared their concerns with Reddit's r/AskAPlumber forum.
Here's what to know
In the Reddit thread, the original poster wrote, "My neighbor, whose home was built as part of my townhome development with mine, just had their heater burst. I know these can last 10-15 years easily, but now I feel like I'm on borrowed time."
OP then asked, "Am I overthinking this? We haven't had any hot water issues."

One of the top comments provided a helpful test for determining whether to replace an aging water heater. The person wrote, "This is my go to when asked this question. When it fails, will it hurt/damage anything? Yes = replace. No = rock on."
Not everyone agreed, though. One commenter wrote that they should've replaced the unit "last Tuesday," while another said to replace it when it fails.
A commenter taking a middle-ground approach explained that "You're approaching its end of life. They usually don't burst like your neighbors'. That's kinda rare. They usually start with a leak. But you might want to start getting quotes."
A plumber who responded wrote, "My Bradford ended up lasting 19+ years. Being in the plumbing business, I have seen them last a couple of years up to 50 years. It really is luck of the draw. But as others have mentioned, if it does leak, will it ruin anything? If not, wait until it goes."
For homeowners choosing a replacement, the type of water heater can also affect household energy bills. Heat pump water heaters pull ambient heat into water rather than generating all of it directly with electric resistance, reducing the electricity needed for hot showers and other daily uses.
If you're comparing replacement options, Cala makes configurable smart heat pump water heaters. Its water-heating schedules can be matched to household demand, helping reduce energy use and bills by planning heating around when hot water is needed. For a household replacing an aging tank, check out Cala's intelligent units.
Get TCD's free newsletters for easy tips, smart advice, and a chance to earn $5,000 toward home upgrades. To see more stories like this one, change your Google preferences here.




