• Business Business

Virginia protesters, some lawmakers push back on Dominion-NextEra merger over ratepayer fears

The risks of an aggressive business strategy can therefore fall directly on families.

An electricity meter.

Photo Credit: iStock

Virginia opposition is building around a proposed $67 billion merger between Dominion Energy and NextEra, with critics warning that residents already squeezed by electricity costs could face even more uncertainty.

According to Radio IQ, about 50 demonstrators turned out near the Virginia General Assembly building recently to object to the possible Dominion Energy-NextEra merger.

Here's what to know

The protest came as state leaders weighed what the merger could mean for Virginia's energy system, utility workers, and customers. Some lawmakers have already opposed the proposal, while others say they need more information before deciding where they stand.

For Fredericksburg-area Delegate Joshua Cole, the complaints reaching his office have centered on affordability, as Radio IQ noted. 

"I'm constantly being contacted by constituents in my district talking about how expensive their utility rates are, constituents who are worried about these transition lines going through their district," Cole said.

Commission members also heard discussion of NextEra's failed merger bids in Texas and Hawaiʻi, where possible added risk for ratepayers was among the concerns raised.

More background

For Dominion customers, the central question is whether a merger would actually lower costs through greater efficiency — or whether households would end up paying for a complicated corporate deal that primarily benefits investors.

Yale Law School professor Joshua Macey told lawmakers that regulators often view large utility acquisitions as efforts to find "real efficiencies." He said another possible motive is the chance to earn returns above the cost of capital through investments in generation and transmission, adding, "This is not a good reason."

Regulated utility customers generally cannot simply switch providers if prices rise or service decisions work against them. The risks of an aggressive business strategy can therefore fall directly on families and local communities.

What's being done?

The main safeguard is the state review process. The State Corporation Commission will examine the merger, a step that could shape post-merger rates for Dominion households.

Lawmakers are also using public meetings to closely scrutinize the proposal. At the recent session, presentations laid out competing views of what the approval could bring, underscoring that skepticism is not limited to one political perspective.

Even those calling for a rigorous review are not suggesting the outcome will be easy. Derrick Max of the conservative-leaning Jefferson Forum said the commission should keep its focus on customers, telling Radio IQ, "If it's in the best interest of the ratepayers to close that Richmond office, close that Richmond office."

Get TCD's free newsletters for easy tips, smart advice, and a chance to earn $5,000 toward home upgrades. To see more stories like this one, change your Google preferences here.

Cool Divider