State Farm employees faced pressure to avoid replacing customers' roofs under a claims initiative introduced in 2021, according to a policyholder's attorney.
Here's what to know
Billy and Lacy Hursh's attorney, Hannah Whitten, said documents released after a hearing in a lawsuit in Oklahoma City show the company tried to cut indemnity and celebrated claims closed without payment, according to KFOR.
Frontline claims staff felt pressure to avoid roof replacements in 2021, Whitten said, and the documents show State Farm knew it.
Whitten alleged that State Farm's practices continue to reduce wind and hail payments in 2026. A full roof replacement requires a team manager's approval, she said.
One passage addresses claims "closed without payment," stating, "A higher CWP should be considered evidence of greater accuracy — the implication is that we are intentionally reducing indemnity dollars and celebrating greater numbers of CWP."
According to KFOR, State Farm denies that it operated such a scheme.
More background
Beyond individual claim decisions, the documents describe State Farm agents' concerns about the initiative and the value of the policies they sold, according to Whitten.
"Agents across the country are complaining that the value of the policy they sell is no longer the value State Farm provides. That's a shocking admission, because that means that the agents are telling State Farm, 'You guys have hidden definitions, hidden exclusions in this policy that are causing chaos in the claim handling side,'" Whitten told the outlet.
She criticized the documents' language as adversarial toward customers. KFOR reported that instances of "tactics" had been struck through and replaced with alternative wording.
"That's so adversarial," Whitten said. "It's like a war term, a tactic against your first-party insured. They're paying you premiums. You owe them duties. You have to treat them fairly."
What's being done?
The lawsuit challenges State Farm's handling of wind and hail claims. Whitten said the exhibit discusses conduct potentially at odds with the Unfair Claims Settlement Practices Act.
Whitten challenged State Farm's representations to the court, saying the documents contradict its denials that it applauded closing claims without payment or sought lower payouts.
State Farm's lawyers want Judge Amy Palumbo removed from the case, KFOR reported.
Whitten said she anticipated a formal recusal motion and wanted a prompt ruling to keep the issue from delaying a trial.
Where can I learn more?
The State Farm dispute puts the handling of homeowners' roof claims under scrutiny.
• An Oklahoma judge unsealed 11 State Farm files in a roof-claims lawsuit.
• Illinois homeowners faced an 8% State Farm hike after the insurer reported losses.
• State Farm planned new California home policies again, but only for fire-hardened homes.
• An Idaho Allstate family said neighboring roofs got fixed while their claim was denied.
Get TCD's free newsletters for easy tips, smart advice, and a chance to earn $5,000 toward home upgrades. To see more stories like this one, change your Google preferences here.







