Oklahoma homeowners seeking compensation for improperly denied roof damage claims could receive a share of at least $35 million from a settlement with State Farm, but accepting the money comes with a condition.
Here's what to know
The Oklahoma Insurance Department identified almost two dozen violations of state insurance laws, including the Unfair Claims Settlement Practices Act, in an examination that led to the insurer's $45 million settlement, according to Beinsure.
The review covered wind and hail roof claims from 2021 through 2025. Independent contractors carried out the examination for the department.
The insurer will pay $2.86 million in examination expenses and regulatory penalties in addition to the settlement. Of the settlement money, $10 million is earmarked for Oklahoma's home reinforcement grant program, and at least $35 million will be held in escrow for eligible policyholders.
The insurer, which denies wrongdoing, according to Beinsure, holds approximately 30% of the state's homeowners insurance market; its closest competitor has roughly 9%.
More background
Oklahoma Attorney General Gentner Drummond opposed tying homeowners' payments to legal restrictions, per Beinsure. However, to receive compensation, policyholders must give up related bad faith claims, and homeowners with pending suits against the insurer must drop those cases. Payments are also limited to the amounts originally owed under their policies.
In June 2026, Drummond filed a lawsuit in Cleveland County District Court accusing the insurer of using an internal strategy that rejected thousands of roof damage claims to safeguard its financial results, Beinsure reported.
The lawsuit followed the Oklahoma Supreme Court's decision to block his attempt to intervene in a private action against the insurer.
Drummond also said the agreement bars additional departmental penalties for the conduct examined and prevents the next insurance commissioner from reviewing the insurer's practices for a year.
What's being done?
Beinsure reported that the insurer has until Dec. 31, 2026, to notify affected homeowners and provide instructions for requesting an independent review.
Homeowners must opt in and submit documentation to participate. A third-party administrator will then reassess denied claims to determine whether payment is warranted.
Oklahoma Insurance Commissioner Glen Mulready said the settlement does not prevent separate litigation from moving forward, per Beinsure. Examination findings can be used in court, but the agreement itself is inadmissible as evidence against the insurer.
"They will have to opt in, and there will be a form to do that, of course, that will be available on our website, and there'll be instructions in the notification on how to do that," Mulready said.
Drummond's lawsuit will proceed independently.
Get TCD's free newsletters for easy tips, smart advice, and a chance to earn $5,000 toward home upgrades. To see more stories like this one, change your Google preferences here.







