FirstEnergy Pennsylvania customers would have spent $82 million less in 2025 if they had used the utility's default electricity service rather than retail suppliers, company data show.
Here's what to know
FirstEnergy can limit which supplier contracts qualify for its "purchase of receivables" program following an Oct. 22, 2026, decision by Pennsylvania's Public Utility Commission. The measure passed 3-2, Spotlight PA reported.
Through the program, the utility buys suppliers' customer bills upfront, then collects payment from households. When those bills go unpaid, other utility ratepayers shoulder the cost.
Under the approved change, suppliers can access the program only for contracts priced at or below FirstEnergy's default service.
The $82 million in additional spending also accounted for customers who saved money by shopping. FirstEnergy reported that supplier-related customer complaints rose by 50% during 2025.
Suppliers fiercely opposed the proposal, arguing in legal filings that losing access to upfront payments would effectively impose a price cap and make operating in Pennsylvania impossible. Consumer advocates, however, supported FirstEnergy's proposed changes.
More background
Pennsylvania residents have been able to choose a retail electricity supplier instead of their utility's default service since the state adopted its electricity choice law in 1996.
Customer switches to retail suppliers do not reduce FirstEnergy's supply profits because utilities are barred from earning a profit on default electricity service.
From 2022 through 2025, households served by retail suppliers accounted for 40% of FirstEnergy's uncollectible residential debt, even though only 18% of its residential customers shopped for suppliers, according to FirstEnergy data.
Under existing rules, suppliers can move customers into new contracts with different prices and terms if customers take no action, provided they send at least two notices before the contracts expire.
According to FirstEnergy's testimony, suppliers often attract customers with lower introductory rates, then raise prices after those contracts expire. Consumer advocates say the practice leaves customers who are not closely monitoring their contracts vulnerable to high, unpredictable bills.
What's being done?
FirstEnergy also sought permission to return customers to default service unless they actively chose another supplier contract. The utility proposed additional protections for variable rate contracts, whose prices fluctuate with wholesale electricity markets.
Commissioners refused to approve those proposals and requested recommendations from a statewide examination by June 1, 2027.
Commission Chair Stephen DeFrank said the review should determine how much additional spending reflects customers choosing offerings such as green energy plans or long-term contracts, and how much stems from "decision inertia," Spotlight PA reported.
In November 2026, Pennsylvania's Office of Consumer Advocate petitioned the commission to reconsider. The office also asked for details about whether the review would include testimony under oath and legal discovery procedures.
Laurel Peltier, a consumer advocate who helped advance Maryland's 2024 supplier restrictions, said of the payment program change, "We'll have to see if it actually lowers rates," per Spotlight PA.
Commission Vice Chair Kimberly Barrow, who voted against the decision, argued that the evidence already supported changing renewal rules.
"We find ourselves squarely in the middle of an affordability crisis, and the customers are asking for relief," she said, per Spotlight PA.
Where can I learn more?
The debate over retail electricity suppliers comes as Pennsylvania households face rising power bills. These stories cover stalled legislation, utility oversight, data center demand, and options for bill relief.
• Pennsylvania electric bills are climbing while proposed fixes remain stalled in the state Senate.
• The state's utility panel is examining how data centers and utility profits contribute to higher bills.
• Pennsylvania power bills are rising again Dec. 1 as AI-driven demand strains electricity supplies.
• Meanwhile, its PPL customers can explore electric bill relief at in-person events with income documentation.
Get TCD's free newsletters for easy tips, smart advice, and a chance to earn $5,000 toward home upgrades. To see more stories like this one, change your Google preferences here.







