An effort to offset rising shipping costs backfired for adaptive clothing retailer Joe & Bella when a higher spending requirement for free delivery drove its purchase conversion rate down by more than half.
Here's what to know
Modern Retail reported that Joe & Bella tried a $100 free shipping threshold in place of its $75 minimum.
"Our site conversion absolutely tanked," Jimmy Zollo, Joe & Bella's co-founder and CEO, told Modern Retail, according to FreightWaves.
The U.S. Postal Service proposed a permanent 11% package fuel surcharge for Jan. 17 to replace its 8% surcharge. The agency filed notice Nov. 12.
The Postal Regulatory Commission must review the proposed changes before they take effect. FreightWaves reported that the same date would bring an average 5.9% rate increase for Ground Advantage, Parcel Select, Priority Mail, and Priority Mail Express.
According to Transportation Insight, UPS has an average 5.9% increase scheduled for Dec. 21, followed by FedEx on Jan. 4.
More background
Jenni Shields, owner of hair accessories shop Evie Pearl Handmade, told CNBC that a shipping label cost $2.93 when she opened. By Oct., a label purchased at the post office counter cost nearly $6.
Shields collects a $6 shipping charge from customers and allocates roughly $1.50 to packaging, according to FreightWaves, citing CNBC.
"I am losing money at this point, and I've really taken a huge hit this year," she told CNBC. "I can't compete with Amazon on the free shipping. I can't do that. I can't afford that."
ShipStation's Q4 2026 Shipping Insights Report polled 1,600 people involved in decisions at U.S. companies employing fewer than 500 people. It found 52% said carrier fee increases and fuel surcharges posed a major challenge, FreightWaves reported.
What's being done?
Lori's Designer Shoes began calculating shipping costs on orders below $150 rather than charging a flat $10, footwear buyer Matt Andre told Modern Retail, according to FreightWaves.
New Jersey menswear business owner Todd Shelton began deducting return shipping from customer refunds, CNBC reported. It was the first such policy in the company's 23 years.
Sarah Melendy, who sells through Troutville, Va.-based Mountain Thyme Honey and Gifts, told WDBJ7 she plans to keep her flat $10 shipping charge.
Founder Lisa-Jae Eggert told Modern Retail in June that TickWise 3 Moms Organics was paying about $8.42 to ship each package — up from $5.36. The Indiana natural insect repellent maker increased its minimum order for free shipping from $75 to $100.
"Raising those minimum thresholds for free shipping is a necessity," she told Modern Retail. "It's not something I want to do."
Get TCD's free newsletters for easy tips, smart advice, and a chance to earn $5,000 toward home upgrades. To see more stories like this one, change your Google preferences here.







