Customers reported depleted savings, property liens, and unfinished pools after hiring a Southwest Florida pool builder facing civil judgments totaling more than $220,000.
Here's what to know
Terence Farrell owns Naples-based pool construction company Goliath CPS. Florida's Department of Business and Professional Regulation ordered him to pay fines and investigative costs for unlicensed contracting in May, according to WINK News.
Among the affected customers were Cape Coral homeowners Jim and Tracy Dunnier, who signed a $74,000 pool contract and paid $60,000.
As permitting delays continued, Tracy said the builder sent them an altered permit application using another pool company's credentials.
"He sent someone else's permit, kicked their name off it, put our name and address on it," she said, per WINK News.
Cape Coral Code Enforcement stopped construction because the project had neither valid city permits nor a licensed contractor. The couple also received a $305 fine.
The Dunniers said they hired an attorney and paid roughly $70,000 to another contractor to complete the pool, bringing their total costs to about twice their budget.
More background
Naples homeowner Matt Simanski paid more than $100,000 after hiring Goliath CPS in June 2025. Simanski said unpaid subcontractors placed liens on his home, and he spent roughly $40,000 to repair faulty construction, replace equipment, and treat well-water stains, according to WINK News.
A statutory demand notice with a March date documented two dishonored checks totaling $19,200 from the pool company to Simanski.
Retiree Bob Colette described a similar experience after hiring the company in 2024 for a $105,000 pool. He said permitting took eight months and Goliath CPS stopped communicating in June 2025 after completing minimal work.
Colette hired an unpaid subcontractor directly, bringing his costs to roughly $150,000.
A site development contractor said he was owed more than $4,000 for hauling dirt and rock, though he declined to place liens on customers' homes.
"Anybody with a conscience doesn't want to hurt the person whom it's really not their fault. They've already most likely paid the builder. ... It's a shame that the homeowners have to suffer the consequences as well as the trades and the vendors," the contractor said, per WINK News.
What's being done?
Records from courts in Lee and Collier counties showed three default judgments: $172,500 for a maintenance company, $37,858.36 for a pool supplies distributor, and $11,336.93 for a building materials supplier.
The latter two judgments named the pool company, its owner, and business partner Britney Marshall, who is no longer associated with the company, WINK News reported.
In the maintenance company's case, Circuit Judge Michael T. McHugh issued an order in October that required financial disclosures within 10 days. Failure to comply would trigger a writ of bodily attachment leading to the builder's incarceration.
Creditors have also pursued bank garnishments. A writ was issued in March to one bank, while garnishment against another bank was sought in June in the pool supplies distributor's case.
WINK News reported that Goliath CPS' primary business number was disconnected. The builder did not respond to emails, and Marshall did not return calls.
For the Dunniers, the losses disrupted plans for a quiet retirement. The couple moved from upstate New York to raise their two grandchildren after two of their children died.
"We just wanted to sit around our pool and live quietly with no drama," Jim Dunnier told WINK News. "That's all we asked for."
Get TCD's free newsletters for easy tips, smart advice, and a chance to earn $5,000 toward home upgrades. To see more stories like this one, change your Google preferences here.







