One city in South Africa said it could not afford to refund customers for unlawful electricity charges, leaving households and businesses facing a potential wait for relief from bills they should never have received.
Here's what to know
Faulty calculations underpinned the electricity tariffs that the National Energy Regulator of South Africa, or NERSA, approved for five municipalities for the 2025/26 financial year. The regulator acknowledged the errors in court papers, according to BusinessTech.
The regulator further acknowledged shortcomings in its checks of the figures supplied by the municipalities.
Proceedings in the High Court in Pretoria on Nov. 9 revealed that electricity charges for Nelson Mandela Bay businesses exceeded the municipality's service costs by 76%, BusinessTech reported. The four other affected municipalities include Ekurhuleni, Emfuleni, Johannesburg, and Madibeng.
Ekurhuleni has strongly opposed the fee challenges, saying it cannot afford customer refunds. The court still has to determine how to provide relief to consumers and correct the unlawful charges.
More background
Melanie Veness, CEO of the Pietermaritzburg and Midlands Chamber of Business, said municipalities were charging excessive fees while failing to adequately fund electricity infrastructure, staff, and spare parts.
"You pay the excessive charges; the municipalities don't spend the money on the electricity functions; so you've got failing infrastructure and the costs associated with that," Veness told The Money Show on Nov. 11.
Her chamber and the Nelson Mandela Bay Business Chamber pursued legal action to obtain cost-of-supply studies, which detail municipal electricity expenses and revenue requirements.
According to Veness, municipalities could inflate those requirements by overstating expenditure and understating ordinary electricity income. Access to those figures gives customers a way to challenge how their bills are calculated.
What's being done?
To protect municipalities from financial shocks, NERSA asked the court for permission to spread corrections over several years.
Veness' chamber is already pursuing account credits through a court order and has lodged formal billing disputes. Members have been deducting amounts they believe they are owed.
The chamber was prepared to seek an urgent interdict against threatened disconnections. The municipality urged members to keep paying their bills, saying credits would follow once the matter was resolved.
Veness emphasized that customers who paid excessive bills should not bear losses caused by municipal and regulatory failures.
"They need to be compensated. They need to enjoy the credits for the overpayments that they've made," she told The Money Show.
Get TCD's free newsletters for easy tips, smart advice, and a chance to earn $5,000 toward home upgrades. To see more stories like this one, change your Google preferences here.







