Homeowners facing rising premiums and a retreat by private insurers could get wildfire rebuilding coverage through a public, nonprofit pool proposed by California's newly elected insurance commissioner, Jane Kim.
The proposal prioritizes modest homes over mansions and aims to keep protection affordable, with a $400,000 cap on rebuilding coverage per home.
Here's what to know
According to the plan, private insurers would continue covering theft, water damage, and routine house fires. Homeowners would contribute to the public pool, while private insurers would cover rebuilding costs above the pool's limit, Bloomberg News explained.
Kim, a former San Francisco supervisor, has proposed limiting the program to existing homes, a measure intended to deter building in areas at risk of wildfires.
According to her campaign website, premiums would have two components: The first would reflect each home's wildfire exposure, based on its setting, construction, and nearby conditions, and would fund claims from a typical fire. The second would help cover years of widespread disaster, when losses exceed what a single household, insurer, or neighborhood can bear.
More background
Owners of almost 700,000 California properties have turned to the FAIR Plan — the state's fallback fire insurer — amid an ongoing insurance crisis.
Property owners have come to depend on the program as private insurers have pulled back. The FAIR Plan insures property worth $773 billion and has received state approval for a 29% premium increase.
Meanwhile, smoke damage often falls outside the plan's coverage, and payouts are capped at $3 million per home.
Kim's proposal comes amid signs of recovery in the private insurance market following price regulations implemented by outgoing Insurance Commissioner Ricardo Lara. Those regulations took full effect in August.
What's being done?
Kim plans to develop the proposal alongside incoming Gov. Xavier Becerra and newly elected state lawmakers once she is sworn in January.
In an interview, she told Bloomberg News the pool would fund wildfire prevention and future claims with any money remaining after it paid claims and operating costs, rather than distribute that surplus to shareholders and executives. By reducing wildfire risk, Kim aims to make insurance more available and affordable.
State Farm, California's largest private insurer, has expressed willingness to work with the incoming commissioner on risk reduction, clearer explanations of policies for customers, and market sustainability, company spokesperson Bob Devereux told Bloomberg via email.
The American Property Casualty Insurance Association, however, warned against excessive state intervention.
"Costly new mandates or regulatory actions that drive up costs or limit coverage options risk reversing this progress and worsening the crisis," association spokesperson Denni Ritter said in a statement to the news outlet.
Kim acknowledged that putting the proposal into practice would require broad participation and negotiation.
"An idea this big and this ambitious should require a lot of stakeholders and negotiating," she said in the interview. "We want there to be a large table that is invested in and bought in to this concept as we work to change a system that is failing many Californians."
Get TCD's free newsletters for easy tips, smart advice, and a chance to earn $5,000 toward home upgrades. To see more stories like this one, change your Google preferences here.







