• Business Business

California insurers won rate hikes without required public hearings, former judge's lawsuit alleges

"Once she raised these concerns, she swiftly found herself out of a job."

A judge striking a gavel.

Photo Credit: iStock

A former California insurance judge alleged she was fired after challenging regulators' use of settlements to approve premium increases without legally required public hearings.

Here's what to know

Kristin Rosi, the California Department of Insurance's former chief administrative law judge, accused Insurance Commissioner Ricardo Lara and the department of illegally approving insurance rate increases, according to the Los Angeles Times.

The lawsuit, filed in September in Alameda County, alleged regulators negotiated settlements with insurers after she was denied the authority to review the requests herself. Rosi argued that Proposition 103 requires public hearings for proposed premium increases of 7% or more.

The proposition prohibits premiums that are "excessive, inadequate, unfairly discriminatory, or otherwise in violation of the Insurance Code." The measure was approved by voters in 1988 and authorizes the insurance commissioner to examine proposed rates.

After Rosi raised objections, she was placed on leave in January 2025 and dismissed soon after.

More background

Rex Frazier, president of the industry trade group Personal Insurance Federation of California, disputed Rosi's interpretation that such an increase automatically triggers a hearing. The department declined to comment to the Los Angeles Times.

Rosi's attorney, Wendy Musell, identified auto and home insurers as the companies involved in the disputed rate proceedings.

More expensive vehicles, increasingly complex repairs, and additional safety requirements have helped push California car insurance premiums up by over 30% since 2022, per the Los Angeles Times.

FROM OUR PARTNER

SoCal exclusive: Save 40% on your electric bill by going solar with no upfront costs

Crushed by your monthly electric bills? Palmetto can take care of you with an exclusive solar offer for Southern California residents.

Palmetto's home energy savings plans deliver all the benefits of going solar with zero upfront investment. For a limited time, special rates in Southern California can unlock bill savings of up to 40% — and you can get a custom quote in seconds without sharing your email or phone number.

Home insurance rates have also gone up significantly due to inflation, higher construction costs, and more wildfire claims. However, homeowners have lost hundreds of thousands in coverage over several years despite premium increases. 

What's being done?

Rosi sought damages for alleged whistleblower retaliation, sex discrimination, emotional distress, and other claims. She maintained that regulators have long negotiated settlements with insurers and consumer groups.

Proposition 103 also allows consumer advocates to participate in rate reviews and recover expenses. Consumer Watchdog, founded by the measure's author, Harvey Rosenfield, says its work has prevented unwarranted increases totaling over $7 billion for consumers and has collected over $15 million in intervenor fees.

"Judge Rosi was in the unenviable position of indicating that the law must be followed," Musell said. "Once she raised these concerns, she swiftly found herself out of a job."

Where can I learn more?

California homeowners have faced higher premiums and limited coverage options. 

• California's FAIR Plan hiked home insurance 29%, leaving residents worried about steeper bills.

• California home insurance premiums jumped 84%, reducing how much buyers can afford to spend.

• A California homebuyer turned to "no-name insurance" with a $25,000 fire deductible amid coverage challenges.

• In California's Inland Empire, even new homes have faced difficulty securing full insurance coverage.

• California wildfire survivors condemned Newsom's veto of bills aimed at holding insurers accountable.

Get TCD's free newsletters for easy tips, smart advice, and a chance to earn $5,000 toward home upgrades. To see more stories like this one, change your Google preferences here.

Cool Divider