• Business Business

New York excavation site had safety warnings before neighboring building collapse killed 8

Court records reviewed by Realtor.com show the company has faced 67 lawsuits since 2012.

An excavator lifting dirt and rocks.

Photo Credit: iStock

A contractor previously cited for damaging a neighboring building's foundation oversaw excavation beside a Brooklyn building where a collapse killed eight people. An unresolved lawsuit also alleges the company's work at another site damaged surrounding properties.

Here's what to know

Townhouse Builders, doing business as Promont, was the general contractor at 2625 Bedford Ave., according to Realtor.com.

The collapsed building at 1321 Flatbush Ave. was a three-story, mixed-use property. Department of Buildings records show excavation work on the adjacent property. Two children were among those killed, and 18 other people were injured.

New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani announced an inquiry after the collapse to determine whether problems at the Bedford Avenue construction site contributed to the collapse. Inspectors with the agency had previously raised safety concerns about the project.

A hotel construction project in Brooklyn is at the center of a 2020 lawsuit against the company in Kings County Supreme Court. The complaint alleges that the company's construction activities damaged surrounding properties.

The company and an attorney representing it in that case did not respond to Realtor.com's requests for comment.

More background

The lawsuit concerns a six-story hotel project at 1200 Broadway, where the company was hired in 2016. The developer alleges that excavation severely damaged 1196 Broadway, while pile driving severely damaged properties at 15 and 17 Patchen Avenue.

According to the complaint, the company failed to inspect the property, prepare an adequate survey before construction, and support walls during excavation and underpinning.

The lawsuit seeks over $1.1 million in damages and remains open, with a hearing scheduled for January.

Department of Buildings records document three violations at 1200 Broadway, with fines totaling $10,400.

In 2016, inspectors cited failures to monitor neighboring structures and safeguard people and property, noting digging equipment had cracked a neighboring building's brick foundation. The failure to safeguard people and property fell under the agency's Class 1 category of "immediately hazardous violations."

A citation in 2017 concerned a failure to track cracking in neighboring buildings while excavation was underway.

What's being done?

The Brooklyn district attorney's office has begun a criminal inquiry into the collapse. District Attorney Eric Gonzalez said in a statement that his office was working with law enforcement partners and the Department of Buildings to determine whether criminal conduct played a role.

The city has also expanded an inspection sweep from 100 to 160 properties associated with five entities involved in the construction project beside the collapsed building. Mamdani and Ahmed Tigani, the agency's commissioner, didn't disclose the companies' names.

Court records reviewed by Realtor.com show the company has faced 67 lawsuits since 2012. Of those cases, 13 remain open.

"If there is anyone or any entity operating in this city that bears responsibility for what happened, we will hold them accountable," the mayor said, per Realtor.com.

Get TCD's free newsletters for easy tips, smart advice, and a chance to earn $5,000 toward home upgrades. To see more stories like this one, change your Google preferences here.

Cool Divider