• Business Business

New York's $4 billion highway rebuild would extend its life to 2080. Residents want alternatives

"A decade is not temporary for the people who have to live next to it."

The Brooklyn-Queens Expressway.

Photo Credit: iStock

A $4 billion proposal to rebuild part of Brooklyn's aging expressway would keep it operating until 2080, but residents are questioning whether preserving the highway is worth a decade of construction in their neighborhoods.

Here's what to know

An environmental review is under way for BQE Central, the section of the Brooklyn-Queens Expressway between Atlantic Avenue and Sands Street. The New York City Department of Transportation is collecting public comments as part of that process, Streetsblog New York City reported.

The plan calls for a temporary bypass with a flyover crossing the Brooklyn Bridge approach in Dumbo. Construction would run for a decade, starting in 2030.

Residents at a virtual public meeting questioned the absence of alternatives from the agency's Oct. 2 draft scope, which compared building the bypass with not rebuilding the expressway.

Brooklyn Heights Association Executive Director Lara Birnback described the review's scope as "far too narrowly defined," Streetsblog NYC noted.

The agency said the deteriorating triple-cantilever structure cannot wait for an overhaul. Transportation Commissioner Mike Flynn has defended rehabilitation as necessary to accommodate the 130,000 motorists, including 13,000 truckers, who use the expressway daily.

More background

Diane Genova, representing roughly 1,200 residents at 360 Furman Street, said the bypass would pass within four feet of the building's façade.

According to Streetsblog NYC, big rigs transport nearly 90% of the city's goods, versus 70% nationally. Alternatives raised during the discussion include the Blue Highways freight initiative, rail, and smaller vehicles such as cargo bikes.

Beyond the proposed construction, residents are already dealing with drivers cutting through their neighborhoods to avoid expressway congestion between Hamilton Avenue and the Atlantic Avenue on-ramp.

Resident Michelle Ocampo described increased traffic on Columbia and Hicks streets, while Layla Passman, the Atlantic Avenue Business Improvement District's special projects director, urged officials to close the Queens-bound ramp, per Streetsblog NYC.

What's being done?

Genova proposed rebuilding the expressway lane by lane alongside a traffic-reduction plan, rather than constructing another roadway.

In 2021, the city reduced the cantilever from six lanes to four following recommendations from then-Mayor Bill de Blasio's expert panel. Daily vehicle traffic on the structure fell 15%, according to Streetsblog NYC.

The panel also recommended closing the Atlantic Avenue ramp. While the DOT has cited potential delays from federal review, former transportation commissioner Hank Gutman said a temporary closure could proceed. He pointed to his closure of a Cadman Plaza off-ramp for retaining wall work.

The DOT plans to complete a final environmental impact statement and begin the city's land-use review in 2028, Streetsblog NYC reported. The project would require City Council approval along with separate state permission to use parkland.

Residents can submit comments to BQECentral@dot.nyc.gov. The agency maintains that stabilizing the structure would still allow future changes to the expressway.

For Genova and the residents she represents, however, the proposed construction schedule remains a major concern.

"A decade is not temporary for the people who have to live next to it," she said, per Streetsblog NYC.

Get TCD's free newsletters for easy tips, smart advice, and a chance to earn $5,000 toward home upgrades. To see more stories like this one, change your Google preferences here.

Cool Divider