• Business Business

City councilor's Toronto water utility plan draws fire: 'Water is not a commodity'

"It's the most important basic need we have, and it should stay fully public."

A wastewater treatment plant in Toronto.

Photo Credit: iStock

A dispute has erupted after city councilor Brad Bradford suggested the idea of privatizing Toronto's water, placing the city's water service in the middle of the mayoral political fight. 

Here's what to know

CBC Toronto (@cbctoronto) reported in a TikTok video that Bradford presented his plan to lower water rates by making Toronto Water its own publicly owned utility.

@cbctoronto Brad Bradford wants to turn Toronto Water into a public utility. Olivia Chow, environmentalist David Suzuki and 15 councillors are criticizing the plan. CBC's Shawn Jeffords breaks down the debate. #CBCToronto #Toronto #CBCNews #Politics #Chow #Bradford ♬ original sound - CBC Toronto

Because the proposal would alter the governance of a core public service, it has quickly become an issue in the mayoral campaign.

According to the report, "Olivia Chow, environmentalist David Suzuki and 15 councilors are criticizing the plan."

Chow said the change could lead to more provincial influence.

The debate over the restructure is about who would ultimately control Toronto's water system.

More background

An altered structure for Toronto Water could affect accountability, infrastructure choices, and how the money collected through water payments is used and distributed.

Critics have suggested the privatization of water could lead to profits coming before humanitarian oversight and environmental goals. Public debate has also focused on the cost of maintaining infrastructure.

One commenter argued that Bradford's utility model "provides cash-strapped municipalities with immediate access to private capital for critical infrastructure upgrades," adding, "Its either this or you pay higher taxs."

However, one commenter, seemingly cautious about the ulterior motives of the "private capital," rebutted, "Water is not a commodity! It's a necessity! It's the most important basic need we have, and it should stay fully public."

Where can I learn more?

Fights over water policy, public control, and infrastructure choices are playing out elsewhere. 

• In The Dalles, Oregon, officials faced backlash over water source ownership near Google's data center.

• In Wisconsin, advocates called proposed PFAS limits premature and irresponsible and demanded immediate action.

• In California, federal decisions on water supply investment could shape long-term water security.

• In Michigan, environmental groups warned controversial state legislative bills could put water supplies at risk.

• In drought-stricken Utah, residents said new data centers would suck water away from communities.

Get TCD's free newsletters for easy tips, smart advice, and a chance to earn $5,000 toward home upgrades. To see more stories like this one, change your Google preferences here.

Cool Divider