A merger between NorthWestern Energy and Black Hills Energy has raised concerns about the effects on customers, and two groups have asked a Montana court to block further integration.
Here's what to know
According to KTVH, the Montana Public Service Commission voted 3-2 to approve the deal on Nov. 10, with conditions tied to NorthWestern's newly acquired ownership stake in the Colstrip power plant. The New York Stock Exchange stopped trading the companies' original shares and began listing their new holding company, Bright Horizon Energy, under the ticker HZN.
But 350Montana and the Montana Farmers Union are challenging the commission's approval. They say it didn't fully assess the deal's risks, which they opposed from the outset because it wasn't structured to guarantee an overall gain for Montana consumers.
They argue the terms could encourage NorthWestern Energy — Montana's largest utility provider — to redirect investments out of state, including to large data center projects.
More background
The lawsuit also alleges that commissioners violated Montana's open meeting laws by meeting privately before their final vote. The closed session followed a question from Commissioner Randy Pinocci about potential lawsuits over the Colstrip conditions, KTVH reported.
Commission staff attorney Pamela Snyder-Varns offered to provide legal advice publicly but suggested the closed session as "a more appropriate forum."
PSC President Jeff Welborn agreed to close the meeting, citing confidential strategy and potential harm to the commission's litigation position.
Commissioners reportedly returned after about an hour.
What's being done?
When they announced the merger, NorthWestern Energy and Black Hills Energy said branding, bill payments, online accounts, and customer service will remain unchanged for customers — at least for the time being, according to KTVH.
Attorney Monica Tranel, who represents 350Montana and the Montana Farmers Union, maintains that the court can intervene even after the merger has closed.
"Under well-settled Montana law, consummation does not moot judicial review or divest this Court of its equitable authority," she wrote. "An entity that acts precipitously to consummate a transaction with knowledge of an imminent judicial challenge does so at its own peril."
Tranel also argued that the presence of counsel or general concerns about legal obstacles did not establish grounds for excluding the public. A PSC spokesperson told MTN that the agency had not yet been formally served and declined to comment, per KTVH.
Neither NorthWestern nor Bright Horizon is formally a party to the lawsuit. NorthWestern spokesperson Jo Dee Black said the companies expected the deal to stand.
"The merger has closed and we do not anticipate the petition will change the transaction. The merger creates a stronger, more resilient company with greater resources to meet growing energy needs and provide long-term value to our customers and communities" Black said.
Get TCD's free newsletters for easy tips, smart advice, and a chance to earn $5,000 toward home upgrades. To see more stories like this one, change your Google preferences here.







