• Business Business

New York council member finds $22.5 million in savings to avert nearly 18.4% town tax hike

"The revenue they relied on is implausible, but the expenses are real."

A marina with various boats docked in a calm water surrounded by lush greenery.

Photo Credit: iStock

Homeowners in a New York town could avoid an 18.4% tax hike under a town board member's proposal to trim $22.5 million from a proposed tax levy.

However, last-minute amendments have raised concerns about the budget's figures and the transparency of the process.

Here's what to know

Theresa Mari said her amendments to Huntington's 2027 spending plan would keep the levy increase within the town's state-imposed limit of 2.68%. The town board approved all 39 changes she introduced, according to Newsday.

Despite approval of the amendments, the revised budget failed in a 3-2 vote. Town Clerk Andrew Raia said the spending plan would therefore be adopted by default. Town Supervisor Ed Smyth noted that the town comptroller was working to reconcile the changes and calculate the revised levy and average homeowner's bill.

Smyth questioned the assumptions behind the amendments, calling them "a work of fiction."

"The revenue they relied on is implausible, but the expenses are real," he said, per Newsday.

More background

The average homeowner would have paid an additional $25 a month under the $269.7 million plan, which called for a $169.9 million tax levy.

The proposed increase drew an angry response from residents, according to Newsday. Smyth, however, argued in August that failing to approve a budget exceeding the cap would amount to "fiscal suicide."

Smyth and board member Brooke Lupinacci abstained on the amendments. Mari, board member Dave Bennardo, and board member Jennifer Hebert voted in favor. Smyth said he received the revisions at 4 p.m., just two hours before the meeting.

Hebert joined Smyth and Lupinacci in rejecting the budget, citing concerns about the process.

"I don't support the way that we went about this," she said before voting, Newsday reported.

Lupinacci also objected to being handed a long list of resolutions she hadn't had time to review.

What's being done?

Mari said she was looking to protect jobs and services during her weeklong budget review, according to Newsday.

Delaying hires for 24 vacant town jobs would save $2 million under one amendment. Another amendment eliminated the town board's $3,000 travel allocation.

A parking-meter revision raised anticipated revenue by $150,000 to more closely match 2025 receipts and 2026 projections. The amendments also added $3.5 million in highway aid that U.S. Rep. Nick LaLota had secured but that the budget omitted.

The town comptroller's reconciliation will establish the amended plan's figures before it is submitted to the county comptroller. Smyth emphasized that the changes required a more holistic view.

"When you change one number in the budget, then you have to change other numbers throughout the budget," he said, per Newsday. "We have to go through the whole budget book."

Longtime Huntington resident Tammy Green said: "I'm troubled by the process. It really needs to be more transparent."

Get TCD's free newsletters for easy tips, smart advice, and a chance to earn $5,000 toward home upgrades. To see more stories like this one, change your Google preferences here.

Cool Divider